A moment that changed me: the tomato pasta that became an obsession – and helped me lead a better life

've ostensibly been vegetarian for 13 years and, in that time, I've eaten a lot of meat. My mum used to leave out the last bit of lamb madras, with a wink, then loudly announce that she was going to bed. I have accidentally found myself in KFC at midnight, hood up, drunk, looking both ways and asking for a Bargain Bucket. My partner once came home early from a night out and caught me red-handed, in bed with McDonald's Chicken Selects. Such incidents were infrequent moments of weakness and, after the fact, I was always racked with guilt. But for most of my vegetarian life, I had felt a certain emptiness; a gaping meat-shaped hole in my heart and stomach.

Then I ate a bowl of pasta. It was 2022 and an Italian university friend, Mattia, invited me to Tuscany. I spent four days with his lovely family, in the rolling verdant hills, with fireflies and fallow deer keeping us company, drinking vernaccia and talking of books and art and poetry. But none of that matters, not even a bit. All that matters is a single plate of tomato pasta from Nuova Trattoria Albana, in Mazzolla, west of Siena. This pasta might have seemed, to the untrained palate, like any other pasta. But it changed everything for me.

A ceramic bowl with a botanic pattern contains pasta in tomato sauce with a sprig of basil

The pici – handrolled Tuscan pasta, much thicker than spaghetti, a bit thicker than bucatini – was audaciously al dente. The pecorino, sourced from a nearby farm, melted like snow. But the sauce, all'aglione (with garlic), stole the show: the chef's wife grew tomatoes in the garden next door, picking them fresh every day. Every forkful made my eyes close and my mouth water throughout the meal. If the great object of life is sensation, as Lord Byron suggested, then I'd never felt more alive.

I've spent the past four years chasing that rush, chasing that . I attempt to recreate it around three times a week, four times a week at Christmas. I experiment with different tomatoes, new methodologies and innovations. I have tried – through reading copious recipes and an immense amount of effort – and failed. Recreating the perfect sauce has proved elusive; it's always just out of reach.

My family and friends are great enablers. I received three bags of dried pasta at Christmas from three separate people who are all too aware of my culinary fixation. My partner once bought me a penne-shaped candle and I was veritably giddy. Then I grew veritably disappointed when I realised it was not penne-scented. My brother gave me a can of San Marzano tomatoes for my birthday. Have you ever unwrapped a present, seen a tin of chopped tomatoes and felt moved to tears? I read when I eat, which means my books are decorated in fingerprints of tomato sauce – and I have come to own a lot of books about pasta and tomato sauce. I just read Ten Tomatoes that Changed the World, for example, which is not the first book I've read about the historical importance of the tomato and will surely not be the last.

Ioan Marc Jones and friend Mattia stand arm in arm smiling against a stone wall in Tuscany

My hobby became an obsession, and this obsession has taught me many things. My first bit of advice, in cooking pasta as in life: embrace the al dente. If you think the pasta is not quite done, it's done. Pasta was once boiled for up to two hours, according to Luca Cesari's A Brief History of Pasta, but now al dente is the default in any serious kitchen. Always buy the most expensive tomatoes you can afford because price usually equates to quality. Never, under any circumstances, add both onions and garlic; it offends Italians – something I learnt by offending Italians. Throw in whole cloves of peeled garlic and half red chillies. Basil should be a late addition, retaining fragrance. Add a glug of olive oil at the end if you're feeling decadent, a knob of butter if you're feeling risqué. Grate pecorino into the sauce, removing the need for salt; simmer low and slow; and avoid the temptation of sugar.

I have not, despite my efforts, cooked a sauce that rivals Trattoria Albana's. Sometimes I come close, finding the right mix of ingredients, spending the right amount of care on each, but the sauce is never quite the same. I am starting to suspect that the perfect pasta owes a debt to the rolling Tuscan hills, the fallow deer, the fireflies, and the company. But I will keep toiling away. Cooking is about the journey, not the destination, and every failed attempt feels like a small success because I have not touched meat now for more than three years. I no longer lapse, no longer take midnight trips to KFC. I may not have uncovered the secret to the perfect tomato sauce, but I have found joy in the pursuit and comfort in my vegetarianism.

Original source A moment that changed me: the tomato pasta that became an obsession – and helped me lead a better life

Back to home