EU 'surrender summit' descends into chaos as Burnham claims deal is done - but Brussels warns it depends on tuition fees being slashed

Andy Burnham's summit with the EU descended into chaos today as the sides bickered over whether a 'reset' has been agreed.

The PM and a host of Cabinet ministers are in Brussels to seal a 'closer partnership', arguing that it is a 'really good deal' to boost the economy and bring down costs for households.

There is already alarm that he is taking the bloc's rules on food, contributing cash and permitting 'free movement' for around 100,000 European 20-somethings every year. 

However, in a brutal negotiating twist, EU officials warned this morning that the terms might not be implemented unless Mr Burnham caves to demands to slash tuition fees for students.

They are setting a six-month deadline for resolving that element, with none of the rest of the package seemingly guaranteed until then. Giving EU students domestic rates could cost the taxpayer nearly £500million a year.

As confusion swirled, No10 sources insisted the issues were not being linked. But a draft statement reportedly circulated to EU ambassadors suggested otherwise. 

Kemi Badenoch and Nigel Farage have both condemned the deal - which could be the precursor to Labour seeking to rejoin fully.

However, penalty clauses are being included that could leave the UK paying billions of pounds if they come to power and pull out.  

Chancellor John Healey, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds and Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband (pictured left to right) are all in Brussels for the summit

Chancellor John Healey, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds and Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband (pictured left to right) are all in Brussels for the summit 

Chancellor John Healey, deputy PM Louise Haigh, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, Europe minister Hamish Falconer, and Environment Secretary Angela Eagle are among the Cabinet stalwarts at the summit. 

Downing Street said negotiations were complete this morning, after claiming last night that they were 'going down to the wire'.

A spokesman said: 'The deal is done - negotiations have concluded.

'Now, both sides will work towards implementation of the youth mobility scheme, the SPS deal and the emissions trading scheme. 

'Both sides have agreed when these will come into force. And those dates are set out in the joint statement, which will be published in due course.

'As with all international agreements, there is a legal process in each respective country which will now take place.

'And talks will continue on some areas - these will be set out in the joint statement later.'

The package includes aligning to EU rules on food to ease border friction, as well as participation in the bloc's electricity market.  

Much of the content had been lined up under Keir Starmer, but Mr Burnham appears to have offered deeper compromises than were previously on the table.

The UK had originally insisted that a 'youth mobility' scheme should only be open to 50,000 people from the EU every year, but that looks to have doubled. 

Since Brexit, EU students in the UK have been charged higher international fees of between £11,400 and £38,000 a year for undergraduate courses. That is compared to the lower domestic rate for British students of £9,790 a year. 

Brussels has been calling for the rates to be slashed to the same as UK students.

And this morning an EU official appeared to connect that issue directly to the fate of the wider package.

'We have given ourselves a deadline of six months to solve this issue, we have been in talks with the UK,' they told a briefing for journalists.

'I think our position has been clear that this is an issue that needs to be addressed. Since Brexit the level of students from both sides studying on the other side has decreased, notably EU students in the UK.

'We think this is something that makes our relationship poorer and we want to address this.

'So we have given us six months to solve this. As for the other agreements we hope they will come into force quickly but we have been negotiating these in parallel and we think that they should also come into force in a balanced way. So this is our expectation and … we think this will be met.'

The official was pressed repeatedly on whether the other elements of the agreement would go ahead without a deal on tuitions fees, and declined to say they would.

According to Politico, the position is being laid out in a statement set to be approved by EU ambassadors.

A draft version of the statement says: 'The Council agrees that adoption of the Council Decisions on signing of the ETS, SPS and YES agreements will not precede the conclusion of the negotiations on the supplementing Agreement providing for equal treatment on tuition fees.'

Mr Farage said: 'Naive Andy Burnham has gone to Brussels and been hit by the stark reality I've warned about for decades. 

'Flexibility is a fantasy. They've used this moment to strong-arm the British prime minister over tuition fee cuts for hundreds of thousands of EU students, and have absolutely no concern for the impact it will have on Britain. 

'It's the same old game, and he's fallen for it out of sheer inexperience.' 

The PM met EU chief Ursula von der Leyen in Brussels this morning, having travelled to the Belgian capital from Berlin last night.

He said 'We're pretty much there, and it's a really good deal.'

He told business leaders: 'Treasury analysis out today is saying that now it's clear up to 0.5 per cent on GDP as a result of the deal.

'The single biggest growth intervention in this Parliament.'

The PM said: 'The test for this summit is simple: does it make life better for people in Britain?

'That is what I will deliver in Brussels today – cutting costs, keeping prices down in the supermarkets and creating opportunities for young people.

'Britain and Europe share values, interests and a global neighbourhood. In a more dangerous world, we are stronger together.

'A closer partnership with Europe is good for working people, good for Britain and good for Europe.'

Mr Burnham has said he is still pushing for agreement on a new 'Channel Action Plan' to deliver greater co-operation on tackling illegal migration. 

Sources indicated it could eventually see the UK sign up to a new EU initiative to send failed asylum seekers to Rwanda - reviving a Tory idea that was scrapped by Labour.

The food and agriculture deal, aimed at ending post-Brexit export checks, would see Britain align with the EU on trade rules on sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) goods, such as food and plants from March 2028.

But the two sides have been haggling over what role Britain would have in setting future SPS laws.

Other areas where there are expected to be commitments following the Brussels talks include economic security covering issues including supply chains and a new digital partnership between the UK and EU. 

Mr Farage accused Mr Burnham of 'betrayal' and added: 'I'm afraid that the great Brexit debate has just started again.'

'We don't need to be in political union of any kind at all to do business and have good relations with our neighbours,' he said.

'That's the betrayal that Burnham is committing today and he's trying to do it incrementally but it's perfectly clear that this very very soon becomes a debate about: do we rejoin or do we stay out?'

Mr Burnham told business leaders in Brussels earlier that the deal can boost the economy and bring down costs for households

He acknowledged that for food exporters a deal on agricultural standards will make things 'a little bit easier' but it comes at the cost of giving up control over regulation.

The Reform leader told BBC Radio 4's Today: 'The Labour Party was elected, saying they would not rejoin the single market. Well, today we're rejoining a chunk of it.'

The Conservatives accused the Government of preparing to 'sell out' British farmers by becoming a rule taker.

Shadow environment secretary Victoria Atkins said: 'They are forcing farmers to follow rules over which we have no say, no vote, and no veto, that benefit highly subsidised foreign farmers, and taxpayers are going to end up paying for the privilege.'

Original source EU 'surrender summit' descends into chaos as Burnham claims deal is done - but Brussels warns it depends on tuition fees being slashed

Back to home