
A rather indulgent holiday in Italy last summer, followed by a busy university term (and perhaps reaching the big 4-0) has left several items of clothing feeling a bit more snug than they were before. I gave up on the scales of sorrow ages ago – they’re currently hiding forlornly behind the bathroom wastebin at the moment as I can’t bear to look at them.
Calculating your BMI (or body mass index) is a generally simple affair – all you need is your height and weight. And if, like me, you operate in feet and stone, rather than metres and kilos, there are calculators catering for those of us yet to fully embrace the 21st century. The result, a value in kg/m2, allows you to see whether your weight falls within, above or below the recommended range for your height.
A BMI of 18.5 to 24.9 is considered a healthy weight. BMIs higher than 25 are categorised into four progressive classes; overweight (25-29.9), obesity class I (30-34.9), class II (35-39.9) and class III (also known as severe, or morbid obesity – is 40-plus). At the other end of the spectrum, having a BMI less than 18.5 is underweight. In the UK alone, it’s estimated that around 30 per cent of the adult population is now living with obesity.
At the other end of the spectrum, having a BMI less than 18.5 is underweight. Unlike obesity, there are fewer formal subdivisions – though particularly low BMIs can be seen in patients with eating disorders, or malnutrition.
BMI is not without its pitfalls though, and a new study published in the has recently demonstrated the dangers of relying on it as a sole measurement of a person’s height and weight.
When you’re making the calculation – accounting for the fact that taller individuals are expected to weigh more – you’re overlooking one important aspect: body composition. What you’re weighing is not just fat, but muscle, bone, water, connective tissue and internal organs, i.e. all the good stuff.
Of those, muscle mass is particularly variable. If you’re tall, play sport, or have spent a lot of time at the gym lifting weights, then your muscle mass could literally be kilos above the average. This is one big limitation of BMI – we can end up assuming weight is due to fat mass, when it’s actually muscle.
Muscle doesn’t just make you stronger, but also supports your metabolism – hence increasing the amount of energy we expend, even at rest. Increased muscle mass is to be encouraged, and sometimes increased weight (and therefore BMI) could be a sign of good health.
I’ve had patients who are 6ft 4 (told you I can’t do metres) rugby players, or who enjoy weight training and bodybuilding, whose BMIs will tell them they’re overweight, sometimes even obese, which couldn’t be further from the truth.
With this in mind, there are numerous things we get wrong about body fat, and BMIs. Here are some of them.
Invest in a measuring tape
Given that BMIs are not always effective, are there better predictors of unhealthy weight? This is where waist circumference comes in – which assesses accumulation of fat around the midriff, which is particularly relevant to health. This can also be used to calculate a waist-to-hip ratio, or waist-to-height ratio – two different assessments which can help determine risk of developing future disease.
A tape measure is used to measure the circumference of the waist (midway between the crest of the hips and ribcage) and the hips at their widest point. This will give an indication of risk in relation to conditions like heart disease and diabetes, amongst others. Interpreting the value is a bit more complicated, as ranges and thresholds vary according to sex and ethnicity.
It’s easy to underestimate the impact of obesity, since many assume that the main negative effects are upon blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar – and therefore cardiovascular health and the development of diabetes. And of course that’s absolutely correct, and not to be overlooked. Some figures are shocking, even for a GP – women with a BMI of 35 or more had a 93-times increased risk of developing type 2 diabetes, compared to those with a normal BMI.
Losing excess fat mass can significantly improve blood pressure, insulin resistance, and cholesterol levels – reducing the risk of developing long-term chronic illnesses.
Excess fat mass can also put extra strain on tissues all over the body. This can lead to increased wear and tear in the joints and contribute to low back pain and arthritis. Fat accumulation on the torso can restrict breathing, causing breathlessness and low oxygen saturations. Obesity can also cause sleep apnoea – where the airways are obstructed at night, and sleep is repeatedly interrupted. This can lead to other serious complications itself, like heart failure, further down the line.
Risks are even more acute in women
Perhaps the most concerning consideration about obesity is its association with several cancers – including bowel, oesophageal, breast and endometrial (womb) cancer. The latter two are particularly relevant to postmenopausal women, since fat-containing adipose tissue secretes oestrogen, which can stimulate the growth of certain cancers. This can also increase the risk of breast cancer in male patients too.
But these are the tip of the iceberg – negative impact on fertility, the development of birth defects in babies born to obese mothers, bladder incontinence and poorer mood and mental health are just some of the wider adverse effects.
Thankfully, medical interventions are becoming more accessible – GLP-1 agonists like Wegovy and Mounjaro are newly leading the way here, whilst older weight loss medications like orlistat appear to have moved to the wings. Having seen the many negatives of orlistat (which is generally less effective and comes with unpleasant side effects) and the extraordinary differences that GLPs have made to some patients, it’s great progress.
There is a risk in being underweight, especially as we age
Maintaining a healthy weight becomes important with increasing age, too. Through a phenomenon known as sarcopenia, we naturally lose muscle mass as we get older. Add poor diet and nutrition to the equation, and this process can accelerate – leaving us with reduced strength, confidence and independence, and increased risk of falls, frailty and fractures. Some patients are also left with fewer reserves to call upon if they fall ill, to use for either energy or healing.
Therefore, for older adults, losing weight isn’t always a great thing – and maintaining muscle mass and those natural reserves is often much better than targeting a particular BMI.
Ultimately, both extremes of weight can impact health in many different ways, but what’s more important is determining key measurements which translate into risk. And real risk, not just arbitrary labels. The real lessons here are in understanding and managing that risk – more so than chasing a number on the bathroom scale.