As a major landlord in Great Yarmouth, David Carter is worried. In recent weeks, six of his flats in the Norfolk seaside town have been vacated. The tenants, migrant workers from Romania, tell him that the time has come for them to head home.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham this week called for an “honest discussion” over a return to freedom of movement between Britain and the European Union.
But Carter is grappling with what he says is a sobering reality of EU nationals looking to exit – rather than flock towards – the UK.
“People are leaving,” he told The i Paper. “They think they’ve read the writing on the wall and they’re going to be asked to leave the UK anyway. So they want to go back home and get a job before everyone else has to do the same.
“The problem is that these are precisely the sort of people we need to have here. These guys are hard working, they pay their taxes, they make their lives here and they contribute to the economy by doing the jobs that no-one else wants to do.”
Do at-home vitamin D tests really work? What we know
At-home vitamin D tests may give unreliable results and prevent consumers seeking help for genuine deficiencies, a watchdog has warned.
A significant deficiency
Vitamin D deficiency is common in the UK, partly due to a lack of adequate sunlight during the winter months, although factors such as diet and age can also play a role.
However, consumer organisation Which? has claimed to have found significant variations across rapid self-testing kit results versus laboratory blood tests for deficiency.
5 min read
3 min read
Testing the test kits
- The watchdog bought five widely available rapid vitamin D tests, all costing around £8 at retailers including Amazon, Lloyds Pharmacy, Waitrose and Boots.
- Results from the same person were compared with a registered laboratory test on the same day, which showed vitamin D levels within a sufficient range.
- However, the self-testing kits gave different results.
50 nmol/L
A reading higher than 50 nanomoles per liter (nmol/L) is considered a sufficient level of vitamin D.
An insufficient result indicates a user’s levels are below the ideal range, while a deficient result suggests levels could pose a risk to health.
75 nmol/L
However, rapid self-testing kits use a higher cut off of 75 nmol/L as a sufficient level.
This should mean more people will be flagged as insufficient compared with an NHS-ordered blood test.
The findings
The Which? researcher would therefore have been expected to fall within the insufficient range on the self-testing kits, given their laboratory result showed them to be within the 50 nmol/L range.
- Only two self-test results in the Which? study suggested .
- Two others indicated – markedly lower than the level indicated by the researcher’s lab blood test.
- The result indicated a sufficient level of vitamin D.
The risks
Which? warned that inaccurate results could leave consumers unnecessarily worried about their health, falsely reassured or buying supplements they don’t need.
The Royal College of Pathologists says taking too much vitamin D over time can cause high levels of calcium in the blood, with complications including kidney stones. Meanwhile, not treating a deficiency can increase the risk of osteoporosis over time.
People turn to at-home health checks for peace of mind and as a way of managing their own health so it is deeply concerning that tests sold by major high street brands and online gave completely contradictory results
Sue Davies, Which? head of consumer rights and food policy
The radical new breast cancer trials to cut radiotherapy
Women with early-stage breast cancer could be spared multiple rounds of gruelling radiotherapy under a “breakthrough” cancer trial. Here’s what we know.
What we know
The Fast-Forward Boost trial is running at 39 hospitals across the UK and will test a shorter course of radiotherapy with an additional targeted dose known as a “boost” to help stop breast cancer returning.
The Government-funded trial is testing whether breast cancer radiotherapy can be safely cut from three weeks to just five days, potentially sparing women 10 hospital visits.
Aim to improve quality of life
- Radiotherapy for early-stage breast cancer is very effective but can be gruelling for patients.
- Treatment is required over several weeks and there are side effects as well as emotional strain.
- Reducing the rounds of treatment may improve patients’ quality of life, cutting travel costs and time away from work and family.
- It could also free up NHS capacity to treat more people.
4 min read
Scale of the trial
1,000
More than 1,000 people have joined the trial.
Researchers hope to recruit more than 4,000 people for overall.
2033
Participants will be monitored for five years.
Results of the trial are expected in 2033.
Builds on prior research
The trial is being led by the Institute of Cancer Research, London, and funded through the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR).
It builds on previous research, with a similar approach already having been adopted for other conditions such as low- to intermediate-risk localised prostate cancer.
4 min read
7 min read
Why Google stock plunged £500bn in a single day
Google’s parent company, Alphabet, lost over $500bn (£374bn) in value on Thursday after it spooked Wall Street with its last update of the year.
Revenue up, profits down
$127.6bn
Alphabet’s total quarterly revenue was up by 25 per cent compared to last year.
Revenue in Google Cloud grew by 103 per cent to nearly $31bn (£23bn), with total company revenue at $127.6bn (£95bn).
- However, Alphabet’s profits fell by 25 per cent during the quarter.
- For the second time in its history as a public company, it also showed negative free cash flow amounting to $9bn (£6.7bn).
Why are investors panicking?
- Negative free cash flow means the company is spending more money than it is bringing in.
- The company’s new level of spending is largely dedicated to investments in AI.
- Google’s search engine now defaults to presenting AI summaries of people’s search queries at the top of results.
- But the company revealed these AI summaries are affecting ad revenue.
The importance of ad sales
The revelation has worried investors because sales of ads that appear next to Google search results accounts for the majority of Alphabet’s business.
Following the revelation to investors, Alphabet’s total stock market value had fallen to $3.46trn (£2.58trn) by the end of trading on Thursday, down from $3.97trn (£2.96trn) the day before. Tracy Woo, a principal analyst at Forrester, said Alphabet’s disappointing results “highlight the challenge of funding massive AI investments while maintaining the strength of established businesses”.
5 min read
3 min read
The most complained about broadband companies revealed
Communications and media watchdog Ofcom has revealed Britain’s most complained about broadband providers in recent months.
The latest numbers
Ofcom said its latest data, covering the quarter from April to June, showed that total complaint numbers were lower than the previous quarter.
It linked the drop in complaints specifically to fewer issues from customers regarding pay-TV services, while complaints about broadband, landline and mobile services stayed roughly the same.
Level of complaints
- Ofcom’s latest data showed BT, EE, TalkTalk and Vodafone reported seven broadband complaints per 100,000 customers.
- Virgin Media was the UK broadband provider to receive the fewest complaints, with four per 100,000 customers.
- It was followed by Plusnet and Sky, which both received five per 100,000 customers.
Change from previous quarter
No change for BT
BT’s figure was flat against the previous quarter.
EE saw an increase in quarterly complaints.
Others see drop
TalkTalk and Vodafone both reported a reduction in complaints.
Sir Patrick Stewart’s life and career – in pictures
The veteran actor, Sir Patrick Stewart, who starred in and has died at his home in Los Angeles, aged 86.
Here, we take a look at his life and work.
- Stewart’s death followed a “brief and poignant journey with Alzheimer’s disease and Lewy body dementia”.
- He is survived by his wife Sunny Ozell, his children Daniel and Sophie from a previous marriage, and grandchildren.
- Sir Ian McKellen, Stewart’s close friend and co-star who officiated his 2013 wedding, led tributes to “the most respected and beloved actor of his generation either side of the Atlantic”.
Stewart’s early acting years
Born in Mirfield, West Yorkshire, in 1940, Stewart began acting aged 12 at an eight-day drama course.
In his mid-20s, he joined the Royal Shakespeare Company, and continued to act on stage throughout his career.
Stewart shot to fame when he originated the role of Captain Jean-Luc Picard in Star Trek: The Next Generation in 1987.
Sci-fi stardom
The sci-fi TV series ran for seven years, with films in 1994 and in 1996. Stewart later said the success of the show created difficulties as directors did not want to cast the captain of the Starship Enterprise in their films.
Beginning in 2000, Stewart took on his biggest movie role as Marvel superhero Professor Charles Xavier in the X-men franchise. He reprised the role repeatedly over the following decades, including in the upcoming film.
Other roles
Stewart’s other TV appearances include , and Fall of Eagles, in which he played Russian revolutionary Lenin. He briefly appeared in in the 1960s and was a series regular on Seth Macfarlane’s , voicing Deputy Director Bullock. He also worked with Macfarlane on and .
Honours and recognition
Stewart became an OBE in 2001 and was knighted in 2009. His various acting accolades include two Laurence Olivier Awards and a Grammy Award.
The lifelong Huddersfield Town fan counted becoming chancellor of the University of Huddersfield among his proudest achievements.
6 min read
4 min read
- Stewart was a vocal supporter of assisted dying, saying that people “should have the choice to die at home on their own terms.” He also called for a “people’s vote” after the 2016 Brexit referendum.
- His other activisim included advocating for victims of domestic violence, having revealed that his father was abusive to his mother. In 2018, he called for medicinal cannabis to be legalised.
What to know as crypto industry suffers ‘largest heist in history’
Cryptocurrency worth billions has been stolen from a major exchange in what has been termed “the largest bank heist in human history”.
What we know
Binance, the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchange platform, was targeted by a “complex attack” involving more than $6.3bn (£4.7bn) in digital currency. Around half of the affected assets have been frozen, the crypto giant said.
Deposits and withdrawals have been temporarily “disabled” but as of 8am UK time on Friday, the hacker was still thought to control about $2.4bn (£1.8bn) worth of Bitcoin and Ether, the two biggest cryptocurrencies by valuation.
Detail on suspected hackers
- Several crypto analytics firms said the hack resembled previous North Korean-linked incidents.
- Binance is yet to attribute blame but said initial investigations suggest the hack “may have started with a compromised DevOps engineer’s laptop”.
- That “gave an attacker access to a service container, where they submitted unauthorized withdrawal transactions”.
The attacker did not simply use one engineer’s permissions, and this was not a single ‘one-click’ action. It involved a more complex attack process.
Richard Teng, Binance’s co-CEO
Unprecedented scale and speed
Emily Taylor, co-founder of the Global Signal Exchange, told the BBC the hack set a “grim new record” and was conducted “on a speed and scale we’ve never seen”.
The hack is thought to have been planned for at least 36 hours and carried out in about 20 minutes. It is understood to eclipse the scale of the previous largest breach, a $1.5bn (£1.1bn) North Korea-linked hack on the Bybit exchange last year.
Binance promises to cover losses
4 min read
5 min read
Could the UK really be facing a ‘catastrophic decade’?
The Government’s plans to help households with the cost of living will not prevent “catastrophic” living standards from falling, a leading think-tank has warned.
Helen Miller, director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS), said in her post-Budget analysis: “This decade looks set to be the worst decade for growth in household incomes on record.”
The think-tank warned the average median income will fall by 3 per cent from 2027 to the end of the decade.
Chancellor narrows his options
The IFS criticised Chancellor John Healey for choosing to fund a £4.7bn black hole in the defence investment plan in part from the Treasury’s reserves. This further narrows Healey’s options to keep spending plans on course in the event of another global economic shock, the think-tank said, and suggests he could face rampant speculation about tax rises ahead of the next Budget.
3 min read
4 min read
A clear short-term risk with the Chancellor’s choices is that next year, with low headroom and a spending review that looks pretty brutal for some departments, we see another season of damaging speculation about tax rises.
IFS director, helen miller
Bacon butties and grumbling MPs: Inside Healey’s first Budget
When John Healey stood up at the Despatch Box to deliver his maiden Budget on Wednesday, he had reason to feel confident.
Does testosterone really help improve menopause brain fog?
There is “insufficient” evidence to back the claim that testosterone can improve brain fog and memory symptoms linked to the menopause, a new study suggests.
Social media is “flooded” with claims that testosterone can improve these symptoms in menopausal women, experts said.
What you need to nkow
While there is anecdotal information that testosterone can help, experts stressed that there is currently not enough evidence to establish the effect. Experts at University College London said testosterone prescriptions have increased in the UK, reflecting growing interest in its role during menopause.
The team reviewed five studies which looked at whether testosterone can improve memory in post menopausal women.
3 min read
5 min read
A closer look at the detail
244 women
Some 244 women with an average age of 57 involved in the review were given either a placebo or testosterone at varying levels.
- The research team did not find significant improvements for cognitive function among participants taking testosterone.
- “The findings should be interpreted as insufficient to establish an effect, rather than as evidence of no effect,” the authors wrote in the journal Reproduction And Fertility.
The expert view
While there may be some anecdotal evidence for this in perimenopausal women, we cannot claim testosterone improves cognition during menopause without further evidence. More research is needed to understand any links between and brain health.
Professor Aimee Spector, senior author of the study and director of the UCL Menopause Mind Lab
The Brexit town on migration front line
Despite its far-flung location on the North Sea coast, Great Yarmouth remains firmly on the front line of the debates that continue to rage around Brexit and migration.
The town, which is towards the bottom of multiple deprivation indicators, recorded the UK’s fifth highest leave vote in the 2016 referendum. Seventy per cent backed departure from the EU after a decade or so in which large numbers of EU nationals had arrived to work in agriculture and the food processing industry.
Local MP Rupert Lowe is leader of Restore Britain, the insurgent right-wing party backed by Elon Musk which is providing Nigel Farage’s Reform UK with a political headache. The party has won support with a range of hardline policies, including a promise of mass deportations of illegal migrants.
Lowe’s supporters in the town are quietly hopeful that Restore’s local iteration – Great Yarmouth First – will sweep to a majority on the borough council in elections next year. A survey last month found that Yarmouth was just one of four UK constituencies where rejoining the EU is not currently the preferred choice of voters.
Migrants and locals ‘live separate lives’
On that basis, it might be expected that Burnham’s flirtation with reopening Britain’s door to a fresh wave of EU migration would be as appetising to Great Yarmouth’s residents as a discarded seaside chip butty.
But when The i Paper visited this week, a more nuanced – even contradictory – picture emerged. It is one of a place where recent migrants and locals live largely separate lives, and yet the newcomers are valued for their contribution to the economy.
As Martin Kirby, 54, who has run his stall selling soft toys and DVDs in the town centre for the last six years, put it: “As long as people are working and paying their dues, I don’t have an issue with bringing back freedom of movement. We probably need these people.”
The grinding work locals don’t want
The once bustling fishing port visited by Charles Dickens – and latterly an entertainment resort which hosted Houdini, Charlie Chaplin and The Beatles – has had several waves of post-war migrants.
An influx of Cypriots in the 1950s set up their own restaurants or businesses. Then migrants from Portugal, Poland and the Baltic states, and more recently Romania and Bulgaria, came to work in the “3 Ps” of picking, packing and plucking.
The labour-intensive, minimum-wage work in agriculture and poultry processing is so grinding that it has little attraction for Yarmouth’s settled, largely white British population, multiple locals said.
The result is that whereas Yarmouth’s Cypriot community is well-integrated, the more recent arrivals have had less reason or opportunity to mix with the local population. Many workers are bussed daily in and out of the town to nearby packing and processing plants where 12-hour shifts are routine, returning to live in rented accommodation concentrated in areas south of the town centre.
‘People felt their town was no longer their own’
Professor Catherine Barnard, an expert in EU law at Cambridge University and a deputy director of UK in a Changing Europe think-tank, has conducted a joint ten-year study of the impact of EU migrant labour on Yarmouth.
She said: “There’s a real schism between the migrant community and the local community. A lot of migrants still don’t have very good English at all because in the chicken factories there are no British people. So they learn the languages of their line managers – the common language can often be Russian.
“From the perspective of local residents, the problem has been that the level of migration meant that people felt that their town was no longer their own. In a place like London, there are such high levels of migration that it becomes part of the identity of the city. That’s not the case for the identity of Yarmouth and it is still coming to terms with that.”
Many of the migrant workers already in Great Yarmouth took up their right remain in the UK under settled status rules after Brexit. About 10 per cent of the 100,000-strong population of the wider borough of Yarmouth are EU nationals.
‘The world doesn’t owe you a living’
Gary, a retired mechanic and life-long Yarmouth resident who declined to give his full name, said: “The world doesn’t owe you a living does it, so I respect people who come here and try to do better for themselves. But people already struggle in this town and it’s easy for resentment to build. We have to find a balance.”
Stephen Ledington, a butcher of 14 years who opened his business in Yarmouth’s revamped market place in 2022, added: “Freedom of movement has been a double-edged sword. I don’t see how you can have a problem with people coming here legally to work and benefit the economy. I’ve worked with Romanian guys and they are hard workers.
“The problems come if people come here and look to do things like exploit the benefits system. But the real problem is that regardless of where you are from, people feel ground down by the economy. Whatever changes are made, people feel they have less in their pocket.”
‘There is nothing here for these people – why would more come?’
A little over half a mile away in a store specialising in Portuguese, Brazilian and east European foods, that same sense of struggle is shared.
Catia Quental, 48, who has run her All In One Mini Market since arriving from Portugal in 2012, said: “I think a lot of people are already deciding to go home. The only reason you leave your native country is to have a better life – to save and raise a family – and for a long time the UK offered that.
“But now the economy is not so strong and for many people they work hard just to pay their bills and eat,” she said. “There is nothing for those people here, so why would more come?”
Government statistics rank the town as the 18th most deprived local authority district in England (out of 296). A third of its neighbourhoods feature in the top 20 per cent of the country’s most deprived areas.
The borough has the lowest proportion of university degree holders in the country and more than a third of children entering secondary school were at risk of becoming “NEET” – not in education, employment or training, a 2022 study found.
Carter, the landlord, said he would like to see a job requirement attached to any return of freedom of movement rules. He added: “Right now, I genuinely think we’re chasing away the wrong people. If we should be getting anyone out, it’s the English people who just don’t want to work.”
Prof Barnard said the number of “pull factors” that brought EU migrants to the area has diminished. And many of those who arrived in the early 2000s and opted to remain are now prematurely developing health problems due to the intensely physical nature of their work. In the meantime, both the poultry processing sector and farmers warn they routinely face struggles to source labour from home or abroad.
‘It is a question of getting people to work together’
Yet there is a sense that all is far from being lost for a town that was this week packed with half-term visitors and has enjoyed significant investment in new facilities, including a renovated £5m market and a £26m seafront leisure centre.
In the marketplace, retired NHS surgeon Hugh Sturzaker was found with volunteer colleagues from the Great Yarmouth Civic Society filling planters placed outside shops as part of a scheme to enhance the town centre.
Sturzaker, 86, who has lived in Yarmouth for nearly 60 years, said: “Some people have told me they feel threatened walking into areas with migrant housing. I have to say I have never felt unsafe. The point is that there is so much potential in this town. It is just a question getting rid of the negativity and getting people together.”