The past is a foreign country. But that’s where Andy Burnham seems happiest living.
The ‘deal’ he concluded with the European Union yesterday takes Britain backwards – back to more migration from the EU, back to the EU setting rules for British businesses we can’t veto, back into the interminable process of seeing Brussels expand its reach into all our lives.
Our leader clearly pines for the days when the greatest compliment a British Prime Minister could be paid was to have his hair ruffled by the president of the European Commission and told he was a good boy for agreeing to her demands.
But while Mr Burnham may want to turn the clock back to before 2016, when the British people actually had a say in our future, the pace of events across the globe is making his journey back in time look not so much a quaint exercise in nostalgia as an error of historic dimensions.
The biggest economic event of this week didn’t occur in the growth desert of Europe, and wasn’t fostered by the innovation black hole that is Brussels. In the US, the AI giant Anthropic offered shares to the buying public and raised more than $80billion, taking the value of the company to $1.5trillion.
Even the most cock-eyedly optimistic interpretation of Burnham’s deal puts the potential gain to the entire British economy at £17billion – around a hundredth of Anthropic’s worth – at best.
But this deal won’t even deliver the tuppenny-ha’penny benefits Burnham boasts of. Because it confirms Burnham wants to turn his back on the growth promise of the future and embrace the failed economic model of the past.
The deal involves Britain entering into what’s called ‘dynamic alignment’ with the EU. What that means in plain English is accepting without question, quibble or demur – let alone a veto – huge swathes of new EU regulations.

The ‘deal’ Prime Minister Andy Burnham concluded with the European Union yesterday takes Britain backwards, writes Michael Gove

It is hard to think of both a more blatant finger-flick to the voters or a worse way for the PM to use the precious gift of office, says Gove
The European Commission will be able to impose on the British economy a rulebook we will have to copy and paste into British law without Parliament being able to change a single word.
Every protectionist lobby across Europe will be able to badger Brussels for tighter rules for any business where Britain might gain an edge; any enterprise which risks out-innovating the Continent.
French farmers and German bankers will be able to get their politicians to impose laws on our firms. Yet we will have no option but to accept not just those rules but their interpretation by a European Court whose explicit mission is promoting Europe’s integration – not Britain’s interests. This will mean giving up freedom in order to have our growth further stifled. It will prove to be a crushing of the dynamic.
One of the least reported, but most significant, areas in which Britain has already been out-innovating the Continent is agritech. We have been developing the gene-editing technology and precision-breeding methods which can increase crop yields, reduce the need for chemicals on our soils and make food much, much cheaper in the long term.
Alongside that, currently British farmers are free to use techniques and products which are banned in the EU and which give us a decisive productive edge.
At a stroke, Burnham’s deal surrenders our ability to do anything – anything at all – which makes our farmers more efficient now or in the future.
At a time when food security matters more than ever and the market for high-quality produce across the world is only growing, we have given up our ability to make our food supplies more secure or gain a leading share in that new market.
And the EU already has its eye on extending its hold over other impressive areas of our economy.
Free from Europe’s burdensome bureaucracy, we have been building on our native edge in tech, data and artificial intelligence. While the US and China dominate these sectors we are, currently, in third place. It’s a tribute to the brilliance of our scientists and entrepreneurs, such as DeepMind’s Demis Hassabis and Mustafa Suleyman.
The EU has made no secret of the fact that its next ambition is to bring ever more of the UK’s economy under the control of its single market. And Burnham has made it equally clear that the only choice he wants to put to the British people is not whether or not we accept greater EU control – that direction is clear – but rather how we cede.
Yesterday, he promised a ‘brainstorming’ session with the EU next year over how we can get even closer.
Just a few months after he pledged to the people of Makerfield that he didn’t want to restart the debates of the Brexit years, he now wants 2027 to become one long debate about just how far, and how fast, we can reverse that democratic decision.
It is hard to think of both a more blatant finger-flick to the voters or a worse way for the PM to use the precious gift of office.
It’s not just that every minute spent discussing directives, framework agreements, protocols and common rulebooks with the EU is a minute taken away from thinking about how to reform welfare, improve schools or sharpen defence procurement.
It is also the case that uncertainty about the precise arrangements we will have with the EU is a growth-killer more toxic than paraquat.
If you’re a tech investor from the US, you won’t send your business here in case you’re legislated out of existence within the year. A financial or professional services firm considering growth won’t know whether or not it should get ready for new EU rules in the months to come, or if it will manage to escape their grip.
Industries won’t be sure how much the EU’s energy regime and attachment to Net Zero orthodoxy will affect their plans.
And they will conclude that other countries, free from that regulatory planning blight, are where the investment and jobs will go.
Those won’t be the only employment opportunities lost to Brits. The new EU youth mobility scheme already agreed yesterday will enable European workers to come here looking for opportunities, even though nearly one million young people in the UK are not in education, employment or training.
Outside the EU, Britain is growing faster than France or Germany thanks to our innovators. So we will be a magnet for their workers. The pressure on every vacancy will grow.
The recurring weakness of the British economy has been its preference for importing cheap foreign labour over improving domestic productivity. Rather than training our own, we ship in cheaper foreign workers. The strain on our public services grows but the latent potential of our own economy shrinks.

Michael Gove and Boris Johnson hold a press conference at Brexit HQ after Vote Leave's victory in the 2016 EU referendum
The irony, too bitter for words, is that the British people have voted again and again to reject an economic model based on more migration, less control, more regulation and less growth. But that is what the new EU deal cements, and what the Burnham project of ever-closer union with the EU guarantees.
It is not even as though this exercise is being conducted by our ministers with ruthless, cold-eyed Machiavellianism – which is the one thing the EU’s own leaders excel at.
At every point in our ‘reset’ with the EU it has been game, set and match to Brussels.
We have already paid handsomely over the odds to enter the EU’s student exchange scheme, Erasmus+. At £570million, it costs considerably more than the Turing scheme it replaced. We are also on the hook for payments if we want to be part of the EU’s energy and defence arrangements, even though we have energy resources the EU lacks and defence capabilities most members cannot even begin to match.
The EU knows that Burnham has already defined success as getting closer still. It knows that he has made Britain a supplicant desperate for more Europe, rather than a negotiating equal ready to walk away if the terms don’t suit us. That means it will demand more and more before eventually getting us to sign.
It has already made further ‘progress’ dependent on us lowering university fees for EU students well below the rates offered to other foreign undergrads. It will get British students – and, for that matter, Australian, Canadian and American ones – to subsidise their studies here.
And there’s a reason, of course, why this has been put so prominently on the agenda for the next concession. The UK has twice as many universities in the world’s top 50 as the entire EU put together. So an EU which can’t, despite its 450million population and $22trillion GDP, even begin to get near to our level of educational excellence wants us to pay for its young people to learn from the best.
That, of course, is not the limit of the EU’s ambitions. Or Burnham’s folly. He has expressed his own preference for Britain to rejoin the bloc – an outcome welcomed by Czech PM Andrej Babis, who said: ‘Yes, of course, we need more money.’ British taxpayers’ money.
Just as the EU’s growth slows further, its ambitions to expand continue, and it expects Britain to be on the hook. There’s no prospect of any restoration of the rebate on EU membership costs that Margaret Thatcher once secured. Not with Burnham negotiating. So independent estimates put the cost at somewhere around £750million a week.
There has been a tragic pattern in British history of attractive and personable politicians who have become Prime Minister after a long apprenticeship and who have sought to etch their names in history with a momentous foreign policy departure. Often they have been haunted by what they see as the mistakes of the past, but their preoccupation with a world that has gone by blinds them to new realities.
Neville Chamberlain was so affected by the shadow of the First World War he embraced the folly of appeasement and concluded a humiliating deal in Munich. Anthony Eden was, in turn, so captured by memories of Munich that he stumbled into the disaster of Suez – a mistake in the opposite direction, but one which owed just as much to a failure to read the future.
And John Major, when he agitated for joining the European Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) and then signed the Maastricht Treaty, was preoccupied with putting an end to what he saw as the mistakes of Thatcher in resisting European integration. But he ended up hurting Britain’s economy, damaging its standing and putting it on the wrong side of the growth dynamics of the future.
Now Burnham risks becoming another politician of promise who is shipwrecked abroad. Like Chamberlain, he has been a municipal leader of distinction; like Eden he is a telegenic communicator; like Major he is a man who promises to attend to our daily frustrations rather than deal in drama.
Like all of them, he has waited long in the antechambers of power before ascending to the throne. And, like all of them, he now seems ensnared by the prospect of chasing a better yesterday rather than meeting and mastering the forces of the future.
For all our sakes, let us hope he realises that what happens in other countries, especially the past, is secondary to doing what is right for Britain and its future. And that, instead of giving up power, surrendering money and opening our borders, it is his duty to strengthen our democracy, liberate our economy and put our own people first.