It began with a conversation over the garden hedge, when a stranger popped his head around to speak to Joan Blass, then an 87-year-old pensioner who had just been diagnosed with vascular dementia. A month later, he had moved into Joan’s spare room.
What would unfold was a four-year nightmare that culminated in March 2016, days after Joan’s death, said her daughter, Daphne Franks. The man, 67, had managed to legally marry Joan, then aged 91, in secret months before – despite, Daphne says, her inability to remember her age, where she lived or the name of the man beside her.
Daphne no longer names the man, preferring to keep Joan the focus of what happened to her family. His arrival into Joan’s life had caused the family extreme emotional distress, but the marriage had a consequence many will be unaware of: from the moment he became Joan’s husband, her previous will was revoked, and her estate passed to him.
“It meant we lost our inheritance, but… also he inherited complete rights to her funeral, and he had no obligation to tell us when or where it was, or to invite us, and he didn’t.”
Daphne says the financial loss – an estimated £200,000 – pales in comparison to the mental anguish. Joan, who wanted to be cremated, was buried in secret. The family searched across the country until they found her in an unmarked grave in Otley, a small town around 11 miles from her home in Gledhow, Leeds, and with no connection to Joan.

Cases similar to Joan’s appear to be on the rise and have become known as a “predatory marriage” – where someone marries another person for financial gain or to secure citizenship. The Law Commission reported last year that the “true number of predatory marriages is unknown”, but Daphne says she gets calls “at least twice a month” from desperate families.
“We’ve had loads and loads of cases come to us since this came to light with Daphne’s case and her mother Joan,” Fabian Hamilton, MP for Daphne’s constituency of Leeds North East, told The i Paper.
He is concerned we may see a surge in these cases as the UK population ages and dementia cases increase.
The man did not respond to this paper, but in a previous statement to the , said: “Mrs Blass wanted to marry me and I believed at the time, and still do, that she has capacity to make that decision for herself.”
‘She couldn’t remember his name’
Joan and her previous husband Ron, Daphne’s dad, lived at a small house built in the garden of Daphne’s home in Leeds – the family home since 1959. They were a close-knit family. “We didn’t really bother with keys during the day as we were always popping in and out of each other’s homes,” Daphne said.
Signs that something was off began in 2008, the same year they lost Ron and by 2011, doctors delivered the diagnosis of vascular dementia, an illness that leaves a person feeling disoriented and confused, and affects their ability to think, walk and speak.
Daphne took on a Power of Attorney for Joan, a legal document allowing her to make decisions and act on behalf of someone who needs assistance. But when the man moved into her mother’s home, they were shocked to see how little protection this gave against a man who, Daphne says, could be charming and present himself with conviction as Joan’s carer.

“We thought there must be some legal… remedy to stop this happening,” she said. They went to the police, social services, a solicitor, Joan’s GP. “We’d been to everyone and either they didn’t see the threat, or they didn’t know what to do about it.”
Trying to get him to leave was fruitless. He would be able to walk back through the door because Joan would let him in, even though Joan would ask Daphne who he was and where he had come from. Joan seemingly could never remember his name, calling him “laddo”, Daphne said.
The family took the man to court in 2016 to fight for the right to bury Joan instead of him. The judge at the Leeds County Court decided that although it was “doubtful” Joan had the capacity to consent to marry, he sided with the man. The judge noted Joan had not written down her wish to be cremated, and was unable to find evidence the man had acted with a financial incentive.
“It was shocking,” Daphne says, “it’s why so many other families have said to me they feel the law protects the predator”.
How this man was able to marry Joan stumped Daphne. Both parties have to have capacity, and both parties need to be able to give informed consent.
However, there is no requirement to check medical records when someone wants to marry, regardless of the age of the couple, nor is there any mechanism to inform whoever holds a Power of Attorney for someone marrying – despite marriage overturning the bride and groom’s wills.
Daphne has been working to change this. She trains registrars across the country in the risks of predatory marriage and in recognising mental capacity.
She doesn’t blame the registry office, saying the lack of awareness and training means it could have happened anywhere.
The i Paper tried to contact the man who married Joan but did not receive a response. In a statement to the BBC in 2018, he described his relationship with Mrs Blass as “long, loving and caring”.
He said: “I was not made aware by Mrs Franks, her family or Mrs Blass’ GP of any concerns they had about her capacity or a diagnosis of dementia. The registrars who performed the marriage ceremony believed Mrs Blass had capacity to enter into marriage.”

Daphne and Hamilton have successfully pushed for the Law Commission to recommend remarriage should no longer invalidate a will in England and Wales. Hamilton has also introduced bills to modernise Power of Attorney laws and consent requirements for marriage and civil partnership registration, but he has been frustrated at the pace of change.
He believes the Office of the Public Guardian, responsible for supervising Lasting Power of Attorneys, has in the past been “enormously complacent” and criticised “the nature of their failed investigations into abuse” in the Chamber, but has higher hopes for the new chief of the Office.
The Government response to efforts to stop marriage revoking a will was due in May this year but has yet to be published.
The Office of the Public Guardian, which looks after issues such as Power of Attorney, does not comment on individual cases, but a Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: “We know how distressing it can be when a Lasting Power of Attorney is misused.
“Breaches of trust are extremely rare but the Office of the Public Guardian takes concerns seriously and will take robust action including referring a case to the police where necessary.”
A decade on, the family has moved away, feeling forced to sell the home Daphne had grown up in as it sat next to Joan’s home, where the man still lived. But Daphne says they have “rebuilt” and found ways to remember Joan, including fighting for change.
She says: “Andy Burnham’s father had Alzheimer’s disease, and I’ve always thought, please can I have half an hour with Andy Burnham? I’m sure I could get this moved forward if I could speak to him.”