My three adult children moved back home – this family contract saved our sanity

They call it “emerging adulthood” and it has rapidly become the most talked about stage of parenting. More of us than ever are unexpectedly in it, or to put it more accurately: white-knuckling our way through it.

Previously, emerging adults – those aged between 18 and 25 – were not a direct parental responsibility because they’d left home. Now, mostly due to lack of jobs and economic constraints, our young adults aren’t joyously sharing chaotic flats; they are back in their childhood bedrooms. This is a new phenomenon requiring a different parenting skillset.

Today, 68 per cent of 23-year-olds and 45 per cent of 25-year-olds have boomeranged home. The number of 25–to-34-year-olds living at home is up by one third over two decades. As a result, mums and dads have abandoned downsizing or retirement plans and, right now, many of us are wondering how we’ll manage domestic harmony during the festive season.

Last year, it looked like two of my four children would be living independently; my third had gone to uni, and only our 15-year-old remained. Now, my 24-year-old is living with us and partly with her partner’s parents to save money; my 22-year-old is home relentlessly job-seeking post-uni, and number three will be back permanently after his first year in halls.  

I am close to my kids and enjoy their company, but it is tricky having them as roommates: do we do their laundry? Do we cook their meals? Do they come away with us? And how do our young people contribute to the household budget?

This is the “low control” era of parenting. Our kids are meant to be building their own identity – which is tricky if your mum is still washing your underpants and waiting up for you. For my husband and I, it’s not just the frustration of having to queue for the shower as we head towards 60 that causes friction; it’s the possibility of putting our future on hold. This undercurrent of uncertainty and dissatisfaction can occasionally lead to conflict at home and, as we are the first generation of parents going through this, advice is sparse.

But a new book has come to our rescue: Lost in Place: How to Support, Motivate, and Launch an Adult Child by mum of five and best-selling parent coach Kim Muench.

“You need one mindset shift when your young adults move back home,” Kim tells The i Paper. “You should be parenting ‘with’ rather than parenting ‘over’. You are more a mentor or advisor. You need to start asking questions rather than giving instructions. And begin to ‘listen to understand’, rather than fix. You don’t have to agree with everything they tell you about their plans – or lack of plans – but you should be asking thoughtful questions to gain information about where they are emotionally, physically, or financially.

“You’re not in charge of them; you’re trying to find out more about them as young people. And you’re working the person in front of you and not basing your expectations on who you want them to be or think they should be.”

She believes we should be coaxing our children towards a date for independent living and her book suggests we have a written, co-signed family living arrangement (there is a template!) which you craft together and review monthly, with follow-through if our young adults don’t keep their side of the bargain. Kim says parents need to define one to three non-negotiables.

For me, it was shared meal prep, as I didn’t want to go back to feeding five or six people every night. Now we all take meal duty on as per the contract. The other thing for us was budget. We agreed to stop contributing to mobile phone bills after they hit 18 (not a popular call, obviously) and that we’d review contributions based on the amount of paid work they could find, I also made it clear that domestic duties like laundry, clearing up and the like were my young adult’s responsibility – this is a bit hit and miss, but I can at least refer to the contract when it goes wrong.

We discovered that moving back in means there is sometimes a default where we are seen as parents available to sort things out: I work from home and, at first, was being asked to help with all sorts of minor issues from booking tickets to finding lost items. We had to agree that I was unavailable for this kind of thing, even if I was at home. And often with their younger sibling, 15, living at home, our young adults would get prickly if I was sorting that kind of thing out for her. Again, I had to gently reiterate she was still a child and they were adults. Also let it be known no one a written contract – this caused immense eye rolling – but I would advise you to at least get it written down.

Other common themes for a family contract include agreed financial responsibilities, chores and respectful communication, as Kim says young adults who feel bad about moving back (and many feel shamed) may default to volcanic eruptions in the hope this will deter mum and dad from setting boundaries, asking for contributions, or questioning them on plans. And parents must clearly work out what they want emotionally, physically and financially ahead of any agreement.

“Vague expectations lead to resentment,” Kim says, explaining that a family living arrangement is done in the spirit of trust and co-operation. It’s not a threat or a power move on your part. It’ll need reviewing as you work out why your young person may be struggling to keep to the arrangement.

“Emerging adults won’t respond well to you constantly lecturing them about what they are doing wrong, it will make them feel ashamed. You don’t want to ruin the years ahead of you by pushing them away, but you do want a respectful way of living and good boundaries.

“You have more control than you think if you communicate well and regularly tell them you believe in their ability to do things like get a job, accomplish chores, sort out finances. They need to hear that phrase regularly.”

Other tips Kim offers include:

  • Learn the power of a pause for self-reflection. Instead of jumping to conclusions about behaviour that you don’t like, you may ask what’s driving it and work out if your response is making things worse.
  • Don’t confuse anxiety and intuition. There is so much parenting advice out there now and it also comes from friends and relatives, so we sometimes forget we know our kids better than anyone. We should focus on that and ignore external influences which drive anxiety, which then informs how we parent.
  • Use “I” not “you” statements. So “I am more financially responsible than I want to be for you living back here and it is not sustainable, can we agree you need more independence? (They will say “yes”.) So how can we achieve that to relieve me of the money stress?” Always give your 20-something a deadline on coming back with ideas and be patient. This takes more than one go!
  • Don’t label your young people or expose their story to others. You will need support and somewhere to moan when life at home is challenging, but choose your supporters well and remember labelling a person whose brain is still under construction until their mid-twenties is unfair and unhelpful. They will change if you work with them and nudge them towards it.

As parents, we will always be the emotional barometer of the family, so making sure you look after yourself to stay well-regulated and calm is also something Kim advises parents to focus on.

“It’s about letting them be who they want to be, not who you want them to be,” she adds, “following your instinct and being clear with what support you are willing to provide emotionally, financially and physically. But this will evolve daily and need to be constantly reviewed. I think living with our 20-somethings teaches us a lot about who we are, too, and helps us grow as people.”

Since we started to formally organise the living together arrangement, I have noticed how saying it out loud or seeing it in writing does prompt a more harmonious atmosphere. It’s painful at first, but the long-term gain is worth it, and I am always protecting the long-term relationship which could be damaged if you get this bit wrong.

I’m not saying it’s all love and peace – living with three adults who never return a towel to the bathroom is infuriating – but at least the more important issues are covered and resentment is not festering. And while it is often painful to step back as mum (I really struggle with wondering where they are late at night) I know doing so makes them more capable and shows I trust them. Every day we learn more about each other and ourselves, which is as it should be.

Lorraine Candy is a best-selling parenting author. Her parenting teens and 20-something’s newsletter is on

Original source My three adult children moved back home – this family contract saved our sanity

Back to home