
NHS Tayside has been fined £70,000 after admitting a shortage of safety alarms led to the death of an 82-year-old patient.
High-risk patient Andrea Imrie fell out of her hospital bed after staff took away a vital bed-pad falls alarm to give to another patient.
The health board admitted the safety failure at Murray Royal Hospital in Perth which led to the patient's death on 13 January 2024.
Sheriff Jennifer Bain KC said the health board could have been fined up to £1.5m, but limited the fine because of the impact it would have on patient care.
Sheriff Bain said no sentence could properly reflect the "value of the life lost" or "alleviate the profound impact and enduring grief the loss of life has had on those left behind".
She said: "Mrs Imrie's movement was not detected and she fell, suffering catastrophic injuries from which she died seven days later."
The sheriff said the level of harm caused was high, but said the health board's "swift" investigation and changes in procedures could be viewed as mitigating factors.
Perth Sheriff Court heard that the second alarm system, involving infra-red beams around the patient's room in Tummel Ward, also failed to work.
Her bed pad alarm was taken away and given to a newly-admitted patient the day before she fell and sustained catastrophic injuries.
The court heard staff took the decision to remove the bed pad alarm from the pensioner despite her having a history of falls prior to her hospital admission on 7 December 2023.
'Deteriorated significantly'
Depute fiscal Lisa Duffus said staff were aware the infra-red alarm was not working because the patient got out of bed in the early hours of 6 January and it had not sounded.
The bed pad alarm had been removed the previous day.
Some time later, the pensioner was heard to fall within her room, and staff found her lying on her back with blood coming from her head.
She was taken to Ninewells Hospital and a CT scan indicated she had suffered a large volume haemorrhage.
The court heard that her condition "deteriorated significantly" and she died on 13 January 2024.
It was told that Imrie had a history of falls, had previously sustained significant injuries as a result, and was assessed as being a high falls risk.
The fiscal said: "On 5 January - the day before the fall - a new admission came into the ward who was assessed as a high falls risk and was known to mobilise frequently.
"Due to shortages of bed pad alarms in the ward, there was none for the new patient.
"Staff made a collective clinical decision that Mrs Imrie was more settled, that her bed pad alarm could be safely removed, and moved to the new patient's bed.
"They would not have made that decision if Tayside Health Board had ensured there were enough bed pad alarms for patients."
NHS Tayside admitted failing to ensure that patients who were assessed as being falls risks in Tummel Ward were not exposed to risks to their health and safety.
They failed to provide an adequate system of work for ensuring that room movement sensor alarms were checked daily to make sure they functioned properly, and failed to ensure the system of work was being followed.
The health board admitted failing to have sufficient bed pad alarms available on 5 January 2024 for patients in Tummel Ward who required them to manage their risk.
They admitted that Andrea Imrie - who was assessed as a high falls risk - "had her bed pad alarm removed so it could be provided to another patient on the ward."
Defence counsel Peter Gray offered the health board's apologies to the pensioner's family and said the organisation accepted its failings contributed to her death.
He added that the health board had since taken steps to prevent any repeat of the incident.
He said: "It is a matter of great concern and regret in equal measure that Andrea Imrie suffered a fall, the consequence of which she sustained severe injury and died as a result of the failings for which the accused organisation is responsible.
"The two failings were not in any sense deliberate and were isolated failings in the management of risks.
"It arose as a result of a genuine, but misplaced, opinion that the placing of sensors and bed alarms were suitable."