Gavin and Stacey gave us some of the best television characters ever created. There was Nessa (Ruth Jones), the no-nonsense, chain-smoking Welsh woman who had an extremely colourful past; Gavin’s mum Pam (Alison Steadman), the overdramatic fake vegetarian with a deep love for Camilla Parker Bowles; and warring couple Dawn and Pete, whose insults get meaner each time they hurl one at the other (“you vicious little pig”).
But chief among them is Rob Brydon’s inimitable Uncle Bryn (“it means ‘hill’ in Welsh”). He was old-fashioned, oddly innocent, sensitive and enthusiastic about any newfangled gadget. He could, played by any other actor, have been unbearable, but Brydon played him with such pathos and wit that Bryn quickly became a firm fan favourite. Which is why I was so happy to hear that the actor’s new project was a new BBC sitcom – and so disappointed when I saw it.
casts Brydon as the eponymous Bill, a late middle-ager who comes home one day to find his wife Anne in bed with the gardener. She subsequently divorces him. All this happens in an extremely quick montage at the top of the first episode, and before we’ve even had the chance to engender any worry or sympathy, Bill comes up with a plan.
The student halls in his town have set on fire, and the newly homeless students are looking for places to live. Before you know it, four students are moving in with Bill and his extremely loud cuckoo clock and causing him all sorts of grief – even leaving the fridge door open!

The problem isn’t with the set-up. In fact, throwing a load of characters together who otherwise wouldn’t cross paths is a very common and often successful sum for laughs. And it is quite funny, with Bill’s enthusiasm for his new housemates (he would rather they didn’t see him as a landlord; he is, instead, their “landfriend”) waning with every fairy light instalment and late-night party.
The issue is Bill himself. He’s nondescript, unremarkable, a run-of-the-mill older bloke who likes recycling and is friendly with his neighbours. There is a world in which the writers of – Ben Ashenden and Alexander Owen – push this ordinariness so far that it becomes funny (a la Colin Robinson in What We Do in the Shadows) but Bill is not even dull enough for his dullness to be a trait – he’s just… there. It’s a complete waste of Brydon’s talents as the charismatic, endearing entertainer he’s proved himself to be on shows like (which returns next month) and even his new game show .
There are funny, unique people around him. One of his student lodgers, Hettie (played by the innately funny Ada Player), is so completely away with the fairies that she doesn’t understand that her boyfriend – who has managed to get a place in halls – has quietly dumped her. His neighbour Martin (Nigel Lindsay) is paranoid about “woke” people and spends his days camping out in front of a Marie Curie statue because the “boys on Facebook” are worried it might be their next target. But the funny details of their characters only serve to make Bill look even safer.
Great sitcoms never play it safe – and Gavin and Stacey is proof of that. On the surface it was a love story between a laddy English boy and a chatterbox Welsh girl. But it was those rich, layered, and yes, abnormal characters that made us fall in love and stick with them for 17 years.
doesn’t have a chance at such longevity. And while I’m sure Brydon has little interest in simply repeating his Uncle Bryn performance time and time again (as much as we’d like him too), he does have the acting and comedy chops to do something more interesting – and challenging – than this.