SARAH VINE: Dr Renee, an impressive and clever woman, is the same age as me - 59. That's why I think she's off her rocker to get pregnant now

A new baby is always a source of joy. A friend of mine has just welcomed her first grandchild, a little girl, and I spent a very happy hour or so at the weekend cooing over her.

Having been a bit terrified with my two when they were babies, I’m rather good with the tiny people now. I think it’s because there’s no pressure. I’m relaxed and they sense that.

That said, I have absolutely no desire to do any of it again. Which is why I was astonished to read about Dr Renee Hoenderkamp, who at the age of 59 – the same age as me – has announced she is in her 12th week of pregnancy.

This news has shocked some critics – which is why in yesterday’s Daily Mail the GB News presenter wrote an impassioned and eloquent defence of her decision to become a mother for the third time at an age when most women are embracing life on the other side of menopause.

Dr Renee is an intelligent, impressive woman, and so she makes a robust case. And she clearly has the means and the medical expertise to defy Mother Nature and make this baby happen. I wish her and her family the very best.

But if I’m honest, I think she’s off her rocker. Either that, or she’s overdosed on HRT. Possibly both.

There are good reasons women’s fertility tapers off and fizzles out from the age of about 35-40 onwards. Having babies takes it out of you, physically and mentally. It’s exhausting and it requires incredible stamina and resilience, both things that diminish with the passage of time.

You also need to be able to stay alive long enough to see them off into the world. Mine are 23 and 21 and, although they’re pretty functional, I would say they are still far from fully cooked. Having me around may be annoying, but it’s also jolly useful.

GB News presenter Dr Renee Hoendercamp has – at the age of 59 – announced that she is in her 12th week of pregnancy
Dr Renee previously got pregnant naturally aged 50 with her daughter Alice, who is now eight

Dr Renee previously got pregnant naturally aged 50 with her daughter Alice, who is now eight

Of course, everybody is different: Dr Renee herself became pregnant naturally at the age of 50 with her middle child, Alice, which is unusual but not unheard of. But 60 is not 50, and one’s 50s are when the ageing process really starts to take hold.

Indeed, a recent study by Stanford University found that human ageing does not happen at a slow, steady pace, but rather surges in two rapid ‘bursts’ or ‘cliffs’ around age 44 and, as it happens, 60.

The first wave brings major shifts in the metabolism of alcohol and caffeine (which is why those hangovers start to hurt), as well as changes related to cardiovascular disease risk and skin and muscle structure.

The second wave, around 60, brings dramatic changes related to the immune system, metabolism, kidney and heart function. Blood vessels stiffen, skin becomes drier and thinner as collagen decreases, eyesight can begin to dim, and reduced melatonin production can lead to sleep disruption. Recovery time is increased.

As a medic, Dr Renee must be aware of this. But also, anecdotally, it’s obvious. Many of my friends in their mid to late 50s have noticed not only a change in their appearance, but the emergence of health issues.

In fact, I’ve lost three friends in the space of 18 months alone – one to cancer, two to heart disease. If your 50s are when health problems start to emerge, your 60s are sniper’s alley.

Truth is, a 60-year-old body just doesn’t heal as fast as a 30-year-old one, no matter how many supplements, peptides, Pilates sessions, affirmations or God-knows-what you subject it to. Thanks to science and the surgeon’s knife, we can all look outwardly younger, provided we have the time and money to do so; but inside, we are still our metabolic age.

Dr Renee is adamant that none of this applies to her. ‘I wouldn’t have done this if I didn’t think I was very fit and healthy for a 59-year-old.’ Fair enough – but what if that were to change? Where would that leave her baby?

She says that when she had her first child in her 20s, her son who is now 37, she was simply not ready emotionally to cope. She was a single mother whose focus was on her career – he grew up with nannies and she, Renee admits, was largely absent.

It’s that absence, she believes, that led him to become a ‘cross, hyperactive little boy who was always getting into trouble at school’. Looking back, she ascribes much of that behaviour to a desperate attempt to get her attention. ‘One vital ingredient was missing,’ she says: ‘me.’ She claims this no longer applies; that she is better equipped now than she has ever been to have a child.

I hate to say it, but that’s just not true. She may be perfectly well-placed to a child; but pregnancy is just one small bit of motherhood. It’s what comes after that really counts.

If being present in her child’s life is what matters to her – as she claims – isn’t she about to make the same mistake all over again?

Even if she lives into her 90s, she’s only going to be around for the first few decades of this child’s life, and even then, she won’t exactly be at her peak.

There is also no way she, as a 60-year-old woman with a busy job, is going to be able to cope with a baby by herself. Her partner, meanwhile, is 66.

Are you really telling me that the pair of them are going to be up during the night sterilising bottles and changing nappies?

I’m a pretty fit and active 59, and even I need at least two nights a week when I go to bed at 9pm and get ten hours solid.

If my son (who is 21) comes home in the middle of the night and wakes me, I’m like a bear with a sore head for the whole of the next day. How is she going to manage being up every three to four hours for feeds? Simple: she will need an army of nannies.

Which is exactly what she claims caused her son’s problems in the first place.

There are other considerations too. I have just buried my father, who was 80, after half a decade of declining health, including a heart attack, a series of strokes and vascular dementia. This all began in his mid-70s.

God forbid a similar fate should await Renee or her partner – but if it were to, this baby would be in her teens (she already knows it’s a girl) – which is no time to be dealing with an elderly or incapacitated parent.

Has Dr Renee thought about any of this? I’m not sure she has.

She just seems defiantly determined to have her own way, framing her critics as sexist and ageist.

I am neither of those things – but I just don’t understand why anyone would bring a child into the world when they’re not sure how long they’ll be around to care for them.

It is, I’m afraid, both selfish and irresponsible. And no number of excuses, however well-argued, will change my mind.

Original source SARAH VINE: Dr Renee, an impressive and clever woman, is the same age as me - 59. That's why I think she's off her rocker to get pregnant now

Back to home