Student union warns against self-swab 'rape kit' use

A stock image of a silhouette of a woman standing next to a window. She has her face in her hands and appears upset.

A student union has warned against the use of self-swab "rape kits" after they were "promoted" to university starters.

Nottingham Trent Students' Union (NTSU) said it was "concerned" the kits - designed for sexual assault victims to gather their own evidence - were being "promoted" to students.

Enough, a company issuing the kits - which had its online posts banned last year - claimed the kits could "in principle" be used as evidence. The swabs have not been successfully used as evidence in court, according to Enough.

As part of its campaign, Enough visits universities, where it hands out leaflets and self-swab kits, and claims it aims to raise awareness about sexual assault, according to its website and social media channels.

A video on Enough's Instagram page, posted in November, showed volunteers speaking to students in Nottingham.

In a statement issued on 4 November, the student union said: "NTSU are concerned about companies promoting self-swab rape kits to students in Nottingham.

"Experts, both locally and nationally, have warned that these kits can cause harm, give false reassurance and may compromise important forensic evidence.

"NTSU do not endorse these kits, and we have no partnership or affiliation with the companies behind them."

Nottingham Trent University (NTU) has been contacted for comment.

In February 2025, the BBC reported that victims risked being given false hope, as the Home Office, lawyers and the Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine (FFLM) charity said self-swabbed samples "may not be usable as evidence in court".

A self-swab DNA kit which contain a swab, a vial of water, a plastic tube and a set of instructions

The charity, which sets and maintains standards in forensic and legal medicine, wrote to universities in England and Wales last year, saying they were "opposed" to the use of kits and urged them to direct students who had been sexually assaulted to sexual assault referral centres (SARCs).

Jodi Shaw, manager of the Topaz Centre - a SARC in Nottinghamshire - said she was concerned people using the self-swab DNA kits would not be provided access to "proper medical, psychosocial and safeguarding care".

She said: "Our concern is that they are marketed without any involvement or endorsement by the Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine.

"They don't provide victims with access to proper medical, psychosocial and safeguarding care, and they may not produce admissible samples, which means that they may not be able to be used in court.

"There's currently - as I understand - no evidence that they would be used [in court] or that their availability deters sexual violence."

Shaw added examiners at SARCs were trained "to a very high standard" in obtaining samples, and said it was "unclear" how self-swabbing kits would be used by victims and how their samples would be stored.

In self-referral cases - as opposed to police-led cases of sexual assault - the Topaz Centre stores samples for up to two years.

Adverts banned

Katie White, who co-founded Enough, said the kits could "in principle" be used as evidence in court and that samples were sent to an "accredited laboratory" and stored for up to 20 years.

Enough's website invites sexual assault victims to anonymously report incidents through its own website, and signposts users to SARCs, charities, the police and other organisations.

The National Police Chiefs' Council and charities, including Rape Crisis and The Survivors Trust, have warned against the use of the kits.

White described Enough as a "social movement", which aimed to "prevent rape and better support survivors", and claimed the kits were "one tool to make that happen".

In a statement in 2024, the FFLM said: "There is no evidence base that the availability of such kits will act as a deterrent to sexual violence."

The Nottingham Trent University Students' Union, in Nottingham

In June, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) ruled that Enough's website, a LinkedIn post and a GoFundMe page made unproven claims about how evidence from their kits could be used in court and how many women were raped in the UK each year, following a complaint brought by Sir Martin Narey - the former head of the Prison and Probation Service in England and Wales.

The ASA said the posts were banned because they lacked evidence. Enough said it updated its wording of posts and webpages to provide more clarity.

White added: "We all agree the best, most detailed forensic evidence that you can collect is via the examination at the SARC."

However, she added the kits were designed to be used when victims were not ready to access other support and said they provided an "additional form of evidence collection".

'Unfair burden'

In a statement, Dr Alex Gorton - the director of the FFLM - said: "Whilst no-one is pretending that the current system is working as well as it should to reduce sexual violence, these kits are not the answer.

"The overwhelming opposition from those representing survivors, clinicians, police and legal experts should have prompted a rethink of their rollout. Sadly, that does not appear to be happening.

"It is vital that students who have experienced sexual assault are guided towards the specialist support offered by Sexual Assault Referral Centres, where they can receive the right care with holistic wraparound support."

Chief Constable Sarah Crew, who is the lead for adult sexual offences at the National Police Chiefs' Council, said self-swabbing in "unregulated environments" was not compatible with a "victim-centred, suspect-focused and context-led approach".

She said: "Asking victims to collect intimate evidence alone, at a moment of crisis, places an unfair burden on them and risks both their wellbeing and the integrity of any investigation.

"These kits can create false expectations, lead to re-traumatisation and reduce trust in statutory services.

"Our national policing position is clear: forensic evidence gathered without continuity, control or clinical oversight is at high risk of being challenged in court and may ultimately be unusable."

Get in touch

Tell us which stories we should cover in Nottingham

Listen to BBC Radio Nottingham on Sounds and follow BBC Nottingham on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@bbc.co.uk or via WhatsApp on 0808 100 2210.

Original source Student union warns against self-swab 'rape kit' use

Back to home