
Millions of people could see their council tax bills rise under Government plans to create police “superforces” in England and Wales.
But police chiefs are warning the public could still end up with “less of a service”.
Ministers are currently considering proposals to reduce the 43 police forces across England and Wales to as few as nine.
Currently, the police precept – a charge that forms part of council tax bills – is set by local authorities. However, under the plans, yet to published, it is expected to be standardised across each region.
This would mean some areas where bills are lower than average could face a rise of up to £70 for an average Band D household. However, areas that pay more than the average could see bills fall.
What are police ‘superforces’?
A report by former Metropolitan Police commissioner Lord Hogan-Howe for the Home Office, due to be published next month, is understood to recommend that local forces should merge into nine “superforces”.
These would be likely to be based on the nine current counter-terror policing regions. No final decision has been made, however.
Another potential option is to reduce the number of forces to 20.
The reforms are part of the Government’s wider overhaul of policing that began in January. A white paper branded the 43-force system “no longer fit for purpose”.
The move was backed by Met Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley this month. He called for the creation of “eight to 10” superforces of a similar size to his own.
However, elected police and crime commissioners (PCCs) in other areas have said the plans will cause “disruption” to local policing and harm the accountability of forces.
Plan will ‘weaken public trust in police’
In a letter on Friday, 31 PCCs called on Andy Burnham to “urgently intervene” in the plans.
They said: “All of the benefits of devolution for public safety, policing and the wider criminal justice system would be lost, the accountability of forces to the communities that they serve would be diluted, and the democratic link between the police and the public – that is so vital to trust and confidence – would be severely weakened.”
Referring to the expected reform of the precept, they said: “The creation of nine regional forces would mean a council tax increase for millions of people as precepts will have to be aligned.
“During a cost-of-living crisis, should residents be expected to pay more to merge police forces, for what for many will mean less of a service?”
Which areas face largest tax rise?
Police forces are funded by a combination of money from central government and taxes raised locally. The precept on council tax makes up about 34 per cent of the each force’s funding, but the exact proportion varies from one local authority to the next.
At the top end, the charge on a Band D property in Surrey is £353, while someone in a property of similar value in Northumbria pays £214.
Under the Government’s reforms, the rates across new areas would have to be standardised – meaning those with the lowest precept face seeing bills rise.
It means residents in a Band D property in Northumbria could see an increase of £70, from £214 to £284, according to an analysis of English police force areas, excluding London.
In the West Midlands, someone in a similar property could pay £37 more a year under the “superforce” system, while an Essex resident could pay £22 more.
In total, residents in 19 police force areas could see bills rose. However, people living in 18 of the current English police force areas could also benefit under a new regional system (see graph below for the full list of affected areas).
These include taxpayers in Surrey, where a Band D bill could go down £53 a year, and North Yorkshire, which could see a £51 decrease for the same property.
What will this mean for policing?
Matthew Scott, Police and Crime Commissioner for Kent, told The i Paper: “In Kent, fewer forces would mean residents paying an additional Merger Tax, only to receive less of a service.
“I do not want to see a Merger Tax being added to the council tax precept as a way of funding these expensive reforms by the back door.”
Kent residents in a Band D property could see their bills go up £14 a year under the plans, analysis suggests.
Lisa Townsend, Police and Crime Commissioner for Surrey, said: “These plans seem based on the assumption that bigger forces are better at cutting crime. But as the letter points out – there is no evidence, academic or otherwise, that shows that larger forces perform better.”
When asked to comment on possible tax rises, a Home Office spokesperson said: “We do not recognise these figures, which are purely speculative. We are still reviewing recommendations on police structures and will set out further details on arrangements and costs in due course.”