The £3,300-a-month benefits problem no one is talking about

Want to understand what’s really going on in Britain and how we can fix it?

Join Vicky Spratt’s subscriber-only newsletter, The State We’re In where she breaks down the big issues shaping the country. You can sign up to get it sent straight to your inbox, every single week, here.

Let’s get straight to it: what if Britain’s real problem is a lack of decent work, not a welfare culture of benefits as is often suggested?

Today, former health secretary Alan Milburn published his report on young people and work. A year in the making, based on research from hundreds of interviews with young people, experts, and employers in Northern Ireland, Blackpool, the Netherlands, Belgium and everywhere in between, it is 278 pages long. 

Coming up in this week’s newsletter

  • Why Britain’s real problem is not welfare but wages. Specifically, wages relative to housing costs.
  • The political potholes that lie ahead for Labour on the road to changing the benefits system.
  • Leasehold reform is happening, housing minister Matthew Pennycook has told me in an exclusive interview.

And in those pages, something quite radical is contained: Milburn wants nothing less than a new social contract and social security system for young people under 25.

As I’ve written, this means less in unemployment support and health or sickness benefits for some young people, greater employment support (such as subsidised jobs, training schemes and apprenticeships) and wraparound help, including cash, for vulnerable young people such as care leavers and teen parents. 

Milburn’s new system would stop under-25s from claiming either the health element of universal credit (UC), currently worth up to £429.80 a month, or personal independence payment (PIP) of up to £194.60 a week. They would continue to get the standard youth rate of universal credit of £338.58 a month, rebranded as a “youth allowance”, with those living independently, as opposed to in their parents’ homes getting a higher amount. Overall, this is a cut on what they can currently get. 

Milburn’s message is clear – he wants Britain to move from having a “welfare state to a working state” where more young people are supported to work and where the state works harder to support them to do so. 

This shift won’t only be for the young long-term. As hinted at by Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden when I visited Denmark with him two weeks ago, how the system can be changed for older people is being given serious consideration, too. 

It’s a noble aim and certainly one that would bring Britain in line with other European countries where employment rates are higher, including for people with disabilities. 

However, there is a huge elephant in the room: work and wages. 

The problem is that for people on low incomes, regardless of whether they have a disability or health condition, work doesn’t always pay. 

Consider this: it is now possible for a family of three living in Greater London, where neither parent is working, and one is entitled to disability benefits (such as PIP or UC Health), to be paid as much as £3,300 a month. 

This figure captures the higher rate of PIP, UC, which includes housing benefit to help with rent on a social home, child benefit and council tax support. 

The reason that these figures are so high is that qualifying for PIP because of a disability or health condition exempts a household from the benefit cap, which otherwise caps benefits at just above or just below £2,000 depending on whether you live inside or outside of Greater London.  

Compare these figures to the average hourly pay for a care worker in Middlesbrough: £13.64. Or a nursery worker in Streatham, south London: just shy of £13 an hour. 

Then, unlike with an income from benefits, there is tax to pay.

Given that the average rent in England is now £1,466, it’s fair to say that few people on low incomes are looking at work as a panacea to their problems. If you earn £25,000 a year, that’s just over £2,000 a month after tax.

It’s worth noting that welfare is slightly devolved, albeit in different ways, in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, but, according to the Office for National Statistics, rents are high in those nations too at £1,011, £848 and £879 a month respectively. 

It is not that benefits pay too much. Some work no longer pays enough once you factor in housing costs. Meanwhile, the support available for rent via housing benefit has been frozen.  

The divorcing of work from reward because of housing costs is particularly a problem for younger people who cannot stay living in their family home unless they are able to get social or council housing. These days, that is a golden ticket even more elusive than Willy Wonka’s.

Is it any wonder that job satisfaction has fallen to a record low according to the British Social Attitudes Survey (BSA)?

Much of the coverage of Britain’s benefits problems focuses on how generous disability support can be, regularly implying that the rise in people – especially younger people – claiming it for mental health illnesses like anxiety or depression and neurodivergence such as ADHD is somehow a sign of malingering or that the system is being exploited. 

In some ways, it is. Not by young people, but by unscrupulous private equity-backed companies who offer to help secure a diagnosis for a fee, as Professor Peter Fonagy warned in his recent review of mental health. 

The real issue, Fonagy concluded, is that young people have become mentally unwell because they live in places where work doesn’t generate enough opportunity or income to have a decent life. That is why almost one million young people are Neet, and that is why welfare support, meant for emergencies, has become a trap, filling the gap left by decent work.

For nearly 20 years, I have covered Britain’s welfare state, reporting on the changes which took place under George Osborne and travelling Britain to observe their impact. 

I have visited places where opportunities for good-quality work are scarce, such as Blackpool and Middlesbrough. I have spent time at warehouses where Multibanks supply baby food to parents who cannot afford to feed their children, even though they are working. 

I have interviewed specialist advisers who have warned that disability benefits like PIP are the only thing helping people with health conditions or poorly paid work keep a roof over their heads because housing benefit so rarely covers actual rents these days. 

And I have spoken with former Job Centre employees who have told me in hushed tones that sometimes they felt health and disability benefits were the best thing they could offer someone who was caught in a spiral of poor mental health and job rejection in a place where there were few opportunities. 

Britain’s welfare state, which includes unemployment support, was intended as a “safety net”, but as housing costs have risen and jobs have disappeared in certain places, it has filled the gap for people who have nowhere else to turn. 

Credit where it is due to Labour. McFadden has tried to address this with his Job Guarantee scheme, a pilot offering six months of paid work to young people, which will soon be expanded nationally. And, in recent years, Job Centres have been able to offer more training support for people of all ages, but particularly those under 30 via the Movement to Work scheme. 

Under his watch, housing benefit cliff edges have also been addressed so that people on low incomes are not penalised for working to the extent that they are forced to stop.

The issue of how much money you need to have a decent life, particularly in London, but, broadly, everywhere in the UK, relatively speaking, cannot easily be addressed, though. 

According to the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF), a single person needs to earn £30,500 a year to reach a minimum acceptable standard of living. A couple with two children needs to earn at least £74,000 a year between them.

Years of weak growth, with inflation and interest rate rises now layered on top of poor economic performance, mean that most people in Britain – even those on what were once considered high incomes – are now feeling the pinch. 

Milburn’s new plan for Britain attempts to offer young people a future by incentivising employers to take them on and give them a chance. It is a Keynesian intervention in the labour market to create jobs. Devolution – giving local mayors more power to step in – is a key part of the plan.

Done right, this could work in places like Middlesbrough – where a burgeoning video games industry could change the local economy – and Blackpool – where there is a chance to revamp tourism and entice engineering businesses.

Done wrong, this could pile more pressure on a generation who are at the sharp end of a decade of economic decline and wage stagnation.

The missing piece of the puzzle is a way to provide affordable housing and make work pay. But, then again, that wasn’t in Milburn’s remit. Perhaps because the truth is that no politician, of any party, could currently promise to deliver either of these things. Even though doing so would help people live the lives they want.

Housing crisis watch

Despite rumours to the contrary, housing and planning minister Matthew Pennycook has told me that leasehold reform is imminent. 

Measures from Michael Gove’s 2024 Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act have now been switched on by Pennycook and will take effect from next year. These include giving leaseholders more power and scrutiny over service charges.

And, at some point before Christmas, I am told that Labour’s own Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, which seeks to phase leasehold out entirely, will be back in Parliament.

This means that, short of more legal challenges from wrathful freeholders or an early election, the promises Labour made to five-million-plus leaseholder households are set to be kept.

Read my full interview with the minister here.

  • I have just finished all three episodes of Rise of the Rockstar Chef, a BBC documentary about Gordon Ramsay, Marco Pierre White and Heston Blumenthal. Three chefs who changed British restaurant culture and cuisine in the 1980s and 90s, elevating our food and dining culture, even though they all grew up in difficult circumstances on council estates with little to no financial support to help them. Their achievements are undeniable and incredible, but, of course, I wondered how much tougher it would be to walk their path today for some of the reasons this newsletter has explored. 
  • I have begun to read by David Szalay. More on that soon. 

Original source The £3,300-a-month benefits problem no one is talking about

Back to home