The two big names the BBC is targeting to replace Emma Barnett on Today

In a rare move, editor Rebecca Keating made a public appeal for a presenter from outside the BBC to respond to a job listing to join the team, following the departure of Emma Barnett.

Signing off on Wednesday morning’s edition after a little more than two years on the programme, Barnett, 41, thanked listeners for “having me be a part of your mornings”. She plans to return next year with a new BBC News show.

Barnett’s exit, following swiftly on the heels of Amol Rajan’s departure in September, leaves the BBC’s flagship current affairs programme with just three permanent presenters – Justin Webb, Nick Robinson and Anna Foster.

One permanent presenting post from the previous five will go under BBC News cuts, as part of a £500m savings plan, with a new recruit now being sought to replace Barnett.

Sharing the public BBC job advert for “, chief news presenter”, Keating said she is looking for an “exceptional journalist and broadcaster who has a long track record of conducting news-making interviews”.

Insiders said poaching a big name would help restore confidence in , following the BBC’s cuts, and bring stability to a programme which has seen its audience drop to a post-pandemic low of 5.29 million listeners, according to latest figures.

The agenda-setting show’s audience has fallen by two million since 2016 and is engaged in a battle for relevance as listeners turn to podcasts and other alternatives such as LBC and Times Radio.

One senior BBC news figure said: “The bosses are very keen on (ITV News senior anchor and presenter) Julie Etchingham. It would be a great coup to get her for Today.“

Another insider said: “Sophy Ridge (Sky News’ mornings presenter) would be head and shoulders above the rest. She has admirers in the management. But would an outsider want to join a BBC making deep news cuts?”

Some hope Mishal Husain, who quit in 2024 and now fronts her own interview show for might be tempted to return, but this is seen as extremely unlikely.

The advert promises a “top-tier” BBC salary, with Barnett earning up to £310,000 for her role.

The BBC contenders

But the public advert could “put noses out of joint” inside the BBC, the news figure suggested, with several internal candidates likely to seek the post.

Katie Razzall, the Radio 4 presenter and BBC media editor, is being tried out on the programme. Europe editor Katya Adler is a member of the rotating presenting team, but was overlooked for a permanent position when Anna Foster was hired last year.

Halting the Today decline

The lure of , first broadcast in 1957, may not be what it was, the news figure warned.

“The director-general [Matt Brittin] is closing broadcast TV and radio stations because podcasts and iPlayer are the future. Where does that leave which has relied on being a live ‘appointment to listen’, which sets the daily agenda?” they added.

Emma Barnett Instagram 12 September 2024 emmabarnett Amol Rajan Coming out of that box live now @bbctodayprogramme @amolrajan - make a brew and join us. #morning #r4today #todayprogramme @bbcnews

The BBC said is adapting to changing listening habits and ranks in the top 10 on-demand programmes on BBC Sounds.

There is unlikely to be great changes to the programme’s format of news, eyewitness reporting and long-form political interviews.

But the insider said the programme needed to stop the recent churn of presenters and appoint someone “who is going to […] be there for the long term”.

Barnett is said to have pushed for less political coverage and more “human interest” stories in the mix. Her new show is expected to allow her to pursue that agenda.

A colleague put her relatively short period on down to “a recognition that her strength is presenting solo, as she had previously done on on .”

There had been reports of tensions with Nick Robinson, with listeners noting the pair had gone more than 90 days without appearing together on air.

Barnett was said to have raised concerns with BBC management that Robinson had been “overbearing”. The matter was resolved with no action taken, it is understood, and there was no suggestion Robinson had done anything wrong.

It is understood that Barnett’s new show will premiere on BBC iPlayer and Sounds as the BBC shifts its focus from traditional linear channels to online-only viewing.

The BBC and Barnett were approached for comment.

John McAndrew, BBC News director of programmes, said: “Emma has been a terrific host for the past two and a half years. She has brought tenacity, flair and energy to the role and she will be missed.”

Original source The two big names the BBC is targeting to replace Emma Barnett on Today

Back to home