Last month, the island of Ishigaki in Japan’s far south-west was the centre of one of the largest military exercises the US and Japan have ever staged. Around 56,000 troops took part, practising everything from missile defence to casualty evacuation. The aircraft carrier sailed alongside Japanese, Australian, Canadian and French warships.
Officially, the Keen Sword drills were aimed at no one in particular. In reality, only one adversary was in mind.
Ishigaki lies about 150 miles from Taiwan, an island claimed but never ruled by the People’s Republic of China. Preparing to fight China over Taiwan – and to defend nearby allies such as Japan in the event of war – has dominated US military planning for years.
Yet, for all the firepower on display, experts in the region increasingly fear that the US and its allies are planning for the wrong war. While they flex their muscles, China is quietly leaning on a different kind of weapon: fishing boats.
On Christmas Day last year, while much of the West was on holiday, analysts at ingenispace spotted something strange. Unannounced – and seemingly unnoticed – over 2,000 Chinese vessels had gathered in the East China Sea and swiftly moved into formation, creating two inverted L shapes, each about 250 miles long.

It was clearly co-ordinated and only discovered because of the vessels’ automatic identification systems (AIS) – positioning data broadcast by vessels to avoid collisions at sea.
Despite near gale-force winds, the formation held for almost 30 hours. This was seemingly repeated weeks later, this time with 1,000 fishing vessels moving into a rectangular formation about 180 miles north-east of Taiwan.
Chinese fishing boats have long been a headache for their neighbours. Earlier this year, Japan seized a Chinese fishing vessel that failed to comply with inspection orders. The Philippines frequently chases away similar encroachments. Since many of these incidents are in waters that China controversially claims, few believe they are simply wayward fishermen chasing a good catch.
But the new formations present a challenge of a different order. By massing fishing boats in giant formations, the fear is that Xi Jinping’s China could quickly build a maritime “great wall” across critical chokepoints. It’s a scenario that should deeply worry the West.
At its narrowest, the Taiwan Strait is just 80 miles wide. Fishing boats strung across it could effectively block one of the world’s busiest shipping routes.

The strait is one of the great shipping arteries, providing the shortest route between north-east Asia and Europe, the world’s largest consumer market. In 2022, goods worth around £1.85trn – more than a fifth of global maritime trade – passed through it, as did almost half the world’s container ships.
If that flow was disrupted, Western countries would face major delays, price rises and shortages. China would have the ability to weaponise this repeatedly, responding to threats and political calculations in its relations with other powers.
China could also use these swarms to impose a “silent siege” on Taiwan’s ports, cutting off food, energy and other vital imports at will, effectively choking off the country that supplies the world with key technologies for emerging industries like AI.
While China’s navy – the world’s largest by ships – poses the more obvious threat, its fishing fleet poses a subtler one. Unlike its navy, fishing boats can hide in plain sight yet still be mobilised at a moment’s notice.
A naval blockade of Taiwan would be a clear act of war under international law, inviting global condemnation and a possible US military response. But a wall of fishing boats is far murkier. Beijing could deny any involvement and other countries may need convincing that a crowd of trawlers is worth escalating into a major geopolitical crisis.
If Taiwan sent in its navy or coastguard to break the blockade by force, it could be cast as the aggressor, handing Beijing a pretext for military action.

The impact of this would be huge.
Taiwan is the world’s semiconductor powerhouse – vital components in nearly all aspects of advanced manufacturing, from guided-missile systems to cars and MRI scanners.
While most semiconductor chips are flown out of the country, a maritime blockade would starve manufacturing plants of the power they need to keep going, as well as raw materials. Taiwan relies on imports for around 97 per cent of its energy needs.
Taiwan makes more than 90 per cent of the world’s most advanced chips, including those that power advanced AI models. Without Taiwan’s chips, the entire AI stack falls apart, scuppering one of the few sources of economic growth in the US and Europe. China’s goal of dominating the AI industry would also get a major boost.
It may sound odd, but China’s fishing vessels could threaten not just Taiwan but the prosperity and security of the US and Europe. And from Beijing’s perspective, the West isn’t watching.
With Donald Trump struggling to end his war with Iran, and Europe facing ever-growing threats from Vladimir Putin’s Russia, China’s actions are getting very little attention.
Trump, Xi and Putin will meet at a summit in China this week, but any talk of Taiwan is likely to be low down the list of priorities, as the trio focuses on issues more fundamental to their own grips on power. Putin is looking for leverage over Ukraine in any peace deal, while Trump is looking for a chance to move the conversation on from the humiliating defeat his party suffered in the US midterm elections. No one’s eyes are on the far east.
But Beijing is growing bolder. This year, for the first time, China’s coastguard began patrolling the waters east of Taiwan, radioing passing cargo ships demanding their crew numbers and destinations.
Analysts see China’s fishing fleet as part of a wider “maritime militia” that Beijing can deploy at will – and they are increasingly operating alongside the coastguard. On 1 October, Taiwan’s coastguard turned its water cannon on a Chinese fishing boat that refused to leave its waters.
China’s fishing fleets are part of a much bigger picture – but it’s a part that has been mostly ignored so far by the West. The , which led the Keen Sword drills, has now been redeployed to the Middle East, reducing Nato’s presence in the region. Meanwhile, China’s fishing boats remain in the waters, seemingly ready and able to respond to a call to arms.