Welcome to Trump’s America, The i Paper’s World Insight series presenting the sharpest, deepest thinking on an era-defining shift in history and politics, investigating how Donald Trump and his administration have changed the US and the world – and where we go from here.
• The revolt in Trump country that could change America forever
Why America keeps losing wars
The only predictable thing about Donald Trump is his unpredictability. In the aftermath of his party’s landslide midterms defeat, Trump gave an interview to CBS News’ 60 Minutes, during which he seemed to be adopting a contrite position.
In that interview, Trump even went so far as to say that he might have been “too tough” with his crackdown on immigration, and suggested there should be a route towards amnesty for law-abiding illegal immigrants who had been in the US for a long time.
Then, just a few short hours later, Trump announced he was promoting Stephen Miller – the architect of Trump’s brutal ICE strategy – to become his new chief of staff. If anyone had been naïve enough to believe that the midterm result would lead to a new, conciliatory Trump ready to work in a bipartisan fashion, Miller’s elevation should be enough to dispel that once and for all.
No one who is not related to Trump has lasted longer in his political inner circle than Miller, one of vanishingly few staff who was with Trump during his presidential campaign in 2016 and throughout his first term, and is still there today.
Miller, 41, was one of the first longtime Republican staffers to join team Trump, having built up a reputation as an ultra-hardliner on immigration during his time working for Congresswoman Michele Bachmann and then Senator Jeff Sessions. Miller would circulate anti-immigration emails to fellow Republican staffers, and encourage the far-right to write pieces on the topic.

That fixation on the issue of immigration never left Miller, who returned to government with Trump in January 2025 as deputy chief of staff, and became central creator of the administration’s mass deportations strategy – and one of its most vocal public defenders.
When immigration agents in Minneapolis shot and killed 37-year-old peaceful protester Alex Pretti in January, Miller falsely claimed Pretti was a “domestic terrorist”, an “assassin” and that he had “tried to murder federal agents”.
Miller has publicly and privately pushed for the Trump administration to go even further than it has in enabling mass deportations, suggesting that “the privilege of the writ of can be suspended in a time of invasion”, and this was something the White House was “actively looking at”. Habeas corpus is the fundamental legal right allowing anyone detained by the state to challenge their detention in a court of law.
Against the backdrop of these and many other comments over the years, it is perhaps unsurprising that more than 100 Democrats put their name to a letter in Trump’s first term describing Miller as a “documented white nationalist”, a characterisation he rejects. Miller might rank behind only Pete Hegseth and Elon Musk among the prominent targets for investigation for incoming Congressional Democrats.
And yet, Miller is the man Trump has just put in charge of his entire White House operation – making him the point person on cutting deals with Democrats to keep the government running, organising the White House response to their investigations and generally managing how the US operates.
Trump could not send a stronger nor a clearer signal than that choice, especially as Miller replaces Susie Wiles, a veteran political operative accused by critics of serving as an “enabler” to Trump, but who is also widely held to have kept a lid on the worst of the chaos caused by an increasingly erratic octogenarian president.
Wiles largely kept internal White House fights from spilling out into the public domain, and kept its various egos in check. Few expect Miller – who has often been among the voices urging Trump to go further and faster in his challenges to the US Constitution – to do the same.
The Trump administration has just spent two years with few practical constraints on its power. The Supreme Court accepted all but the most extreme measures the White House tried to advance – such as its attempt to override birthright citizenship, which is clearly constitutionally protected, and the attempt to fire a governor of the Federal Reserve without cause.
Congressional Republicans went along with almost everything Trump asked of them, and made no attempts to investigate DOGE (the Department of Government Efficiency) or ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement), and kept their discomfort at the Iran war contained.
With Democrats in power, practical constraints on the White House have returned. There is no one to sign blank cheques to finance ICE or Trump’s overseas wars. Congressional committees will no longer focus on investigating Trump’s enemies, but will turn their attention to his inner circle.
Any sensible administration would trim its sails accordingly, and try to focus on what it could get done in a dramatically changed political equilibrium. By appointing Miller, Trump is signalling something very different – he has put his most belligerent aide in the most prominent job possible.
Miller is a fighter, and he will look to take on Trump’s critics head on. Should Miller last in the role, expect the remaining years of the Trump administration to resemble nothing so much as a drawn-out, bloody grudge match – with the future of the USA at stake.