Two explosive days in the making of Fleetwood Mac’s Rumours

Ken Caillat co-produced one of the greatest albums of the 20th century: Fleetwood Mac’s ‘Rumours’, released in 1977. In this extract from his new book ‘Making Rumours’, written with Steve Stiefel, he recalls two tumultuous, history-making days in the studio

One morning during the recording of , my co-producer Richard Dashut and I got to the studio early so that we could check the bass on “Lovin’ Fun” and redo it again if John McVie wanted to. Ten o’clock was usually a great starting time for John because it gave us about an hour, maybe an hour and a half, before his buzz kicked in and he might not be able to concentrate on his part.

After lunch, Christine McVie wanted to do a quick lead vocal. Then Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks were going to add some background vocals. I needed to consolidate some tracks to make room for the new vocal parts. I bounced the two extra ambient drum mics down to one track, and I was nearly ready for the singers.

Often, Lindsey would play just to look for ideas. He came up with brilliant parts in passing – leads or rhythm licks. By recording all of it, I could play back the good parts, and Lindsey could make a whole track out of whatever he chose. He had some truly brilliant moments. I love his guitar-playing.

Ken Caillat, left, and Richard Dashut worked with Fleetwood Mac on their albums Rumours,

Anyway, that day, Lindsey put some nice rhythm guitar parts in and some nice licks. You can hear some of them if you listen to “Lovin’ Fun” at the 10-second mark, the 15-second mark, and again at 2:38 to 2:40 minutes. I love the three high-hat hits, and then all hell breaks loose with the song!

So, in those next few hours, we had made a dramatic change in the track. At one point Stevie wanted to do something, too, and, of course, what she did best was sing. We played around with some ideas, and, eventually, Stevie and Lindsey [who had been in a tumultuous relationship] were sitting on two high stools out in the studio, each of them in front of a microphone, working on background parts, singing: “You make lovin’ fun, you make lovin’ fun…”

When I stopped the tape to rewind it, Stevie suddenly looked at Lindsey and cried out, “F**k you, asshole! You can go to hell!” Lindsey responded with a tirade of his own. “When we get back to LA, I’m moving out.”

Guys gone wild in the control room of studio 4 at Heider?s: me, Cris, Lindsey, and Richard

“I don’t want to live with you, either!” They went back and forth, screaming and yelling at each other.

I couldn’t rewind the tape fast enough. When I got to the beginning of the tape, I hit “record”. Stevie and Lindsey looked at each other. Then they turned towards their microphones and, right on cue, right in the middle of a fight, they nailed their parts.

“You make lovin’ fun, you make lovin’ fun…”

What just happened? I was flabbergasted.

Of course, Richard knew exactly what was going on. That’s the first time I found out that Stevie and Lindsey were having serious problems. I mean, I’d seen Lindsey flirt with other women, and he hadn’t seemed that close with Stevie in the studio, but I just thought that this was how they were. That shows you how naive I was. This back-and-forth fighting, singing, and fighting went on for about a half-hour, and it was contagious. John started fighting with Christine. Soon Stevie and Christine left the room. Finally, everyone who was still in the studio walked outside to get some air.

I was rolling up some cables when I heard Christine playing the grand piano. I stopped what I was doing – it was so beautiful! I just stood there listening to her sing. She had written it at the hotel the night before. Then I did something I’ve never done again. I went over and sat on the piano bench next to Christine. She continued playing and singing, but she looked at me as if she was thinking, Why the hell are you sitting here while I’m playing?

I snapped out of it. I got up and went over to our two-track reference tape, and I hit “record”. Christine played it again, and I got the whole thing down on tape. It was “Songbird”.

About that time, everybody came back into the control room and heard Christine play “Songbird”. Christine was so excited, she was shaking. I’m not sure whether the rest of the band was as excited as Christine and I were. For a studio track, the song didn’t have much vibe or personality. 

hristine and Stevie wait and listen while we mix their song

I showed the band what ‘Songbird’ could sound like with live-sounding reverb. Then I had a brilliant idea. “Hey, let’s record it live over at the Berkeley Community Theater! It’s a beautiful-sounding hall. I recently recorded Joni there.” Mick, Christine, and Lindsey gave me their nod of approval. “Great, I’ll start to make arrangements tomorrow,” I said. I made a cassette of “Songbird” for Christine to take home, and we left the studio close to midnight.

In the auditorium, everyone was counting on me for sound direction because I had the most experience in live recording. When Christine arrived, we dimmed the house lights so that all she could see were the flowers and the piano with the spotlight shining down from the heavens. She nearly broke into tears. Then she started to play.

Christine once said, years later, when the band was talking about getting back together, “I agreed, as long as we didn’t have to play ‘Songbird’. John asked me why, and I said: ‘Because I don’t want to cry any more.’ And he said: ‘You cry, too?'”

LOS ANGELES - AUGUST 1974: Fleetwood Mac (L-R: John McVie, Mick Fleetwood, Bob Welch and Christine McVie) pose for a portrait under the Hollywood Sign AUGUST 1974 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images)

“The Chain” had sat around for quite a while as a different song with a different title – “Keep Me There” – and none of us felt good about it. We all knew that it had potential – it certainly had a great tag, but the chorus was only okay. We needed something equally special for the first half, something that would unite the band and heal their wounds, something written by the whole band for the very first time.

Lindsey wanted to make the verses very sparse, with only a couple of instruments and three-part harmonies as the lead melody. He wanted me to cut out the current verses and give everyone a blank slate to work with. 

Mick and Lindsey decided they would play together. Mick got his largest kick drum out, and Lindsey decided to play the Dobro because he had already used it at the end of the song.

We got a great sound from Mick’s kick. We needed it, because it was going to be sitting exposed, virtually by itself. I wound the tape to where the beginning of the song used to be. I started the click in their headphones, and Lindsey counted it off: “One, two, three, four.” Mick played his famous kick lick that we all know as the intro to “The Chain”, and Lindsey played his renowned Dobro licks through the intro and the first verse.

1975: (L-R) John McVie, Christine McVie, Stevie Nicks, Mick Fleetwood, and Lindsey Buckingham of the rock group "Fleetwood Mac" pose for a portrait in 1975. (Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images)

Then we did the same thing for the second verse. I made the appropriate edits, and we had a new song. We still had the original chord structure from the chorus of “Keep Me There”, but that was okay because the writers needed to write something to go with the new kick and the old chorus drums. We also needed something that worked with that great ending.

Christine, Lindsey, and Stevie sat around the piano for about an hour and a half, working on ideas while we played back our new creation. I was amazed at how easy it had been to completely change a song’s direction. Stevie said she thought she had a melody that could work for the song. Ultimately, the writers left the studio and went over to Stevie’s house to work things out.

Stevie had written another song with a lot of the words that she incorporated into “The Chain” – “I’d asked several times before if I could help on that song, and I’d always been told, ‘No, no, no. You can’t help us,’” Stevie said, but the melody and the chorus of her song went really well with that great ending of Christine’s.

Lindsey Buckingham was brilliant but difficult

So “The Chain” almost didn’t exist, because we couldn’t figure out how to make the great pieces into an actual song. We had gone over it again and again during the preceding months, trying to think of something that would go with the ending. If Stevie hadn’t had that melody and those words, it never would have happened. That’s another example of how undervalued she was by the band at this point.

The next morning, Stevie, Lindsey, and Christine came in, and it was clear that they had a plan. Lindsey replayed the Dobro to the appropriate chords for the new version of the song. He had me erase the old chorus chords to fit the new song, all the way to that well known tag out where John’s famous bass riff enters.

“I remember John’s great bass solo, ‘Doe daaaa doe da da doe doe doe doe da doooooooe.’ And it’s like the monsters are coming! And we all loved that,” Stevie said after we recorded the final version.

So it was quite poetic that the first song we had recorded in the midst of all of that angst 11 months earlier would also be the song that brought the band back together near the end.

‘Making Rumours: The Inside Story of how Fleetwood Mac Made a Masterpiece’, by Ken Caillat with Steve Stiefel, is out now (Monoray, £25)

Original source Two explosive days in the making of Fleetwood Mac’s Rumours

Back to home