Unionists say Government’s refusal of Stormont Brake is ‘completely incoherent’

The Government’s position is “completely incoherent and totally unsustainable” after refusing a request to use the Stormont Brake, according to unionist parties.
The brake was a central part of the Windsor Framework, a post-Brexit agreement between the UK and EU in 2023, and was put in place to address unionist concerns about Northern Ireland’s Brexit deal.
It is designed to give Stormont the power to object to amendments to EU rules that apply in Northern Ireland.
MLAs from the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP), the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP) and the Traditional Unionist Voice (TUV) submitted a request to the UK Government on November 6 to implement the brake, to block new EU customs legislation in Northern Ireland.
It was rejected by Northern Ireland Secretary Sir Chris Bryant on Tuesday.

On Friday, the leaders of those parties, Gavin Robinson, Jon Burrows and Jim Allister, respectively, along with the Inter-Trade UK Business Association chairman, Peter Summerton, questioned the logic that informed Sir Chris’s decision to refuse the request.
In their statement, they said the decision fails the Makerfield test, a policy benchmark introduced by UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham, which judges government decisions by whether they deliver tangible improvements to everyday life.
The statement said: “Given that this week, the Prime Minister has argued that having a trade border in the English Channel between the UK and the foreign countries of the EU is to the detriment of citizens in England, Scotland and Wales, such that its removal can be deemed to meet the Makerfield test, it makes no sense whatsoever that the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland should have judged that the division of our own country, the United Kingdom, by an international customs border is perfectly acceptable.”
The request for the brake was made as a result of revised EU rules for importers and exporters, called the Union Customs Code.
The new legislation will see a single, centralised online portal replace national customs IT systems.

The MLAs who petitioned for the use of the Stormont Brake said the new system reforms would create complexity for business and would increase costs and burdens both within Northern Ireland and for Great Britain to Northern Ireland movements.
They also argued that the EU customs rules threaten to deepen trade barriers between Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
The Windsor Framework, and its predecessor, the Northern Ireland (NI) Protocol, require checks and customs paperwork on goods moving from Great Britain into Northern Ireland.
Under the arrangements, which were designed to ensure no hardening of the Irish land border post-Brexit, Northern Ireland continues to follow many EU trade and customs rules.
In their statement, the group said that the legislation is in breach of their rights under the Windsor Framework, which allows for qualifying goods from Northern Ireland to trade freely into both the UK internal market and the European Union Single Market without tariffs, customs checks or separate regulatory approvals.

“The Government’s position is now completely incoherent and totally unsustainable,” the statement said.
“Moreover, the new iteration of the customs border, in denying Northern Ireland unfettered access to critical inputs and finished goods from the greater part of its home market, provides clear refutation of the notion of Dual Market Access.
“As well as having as much right as businesses in any other economy to unfettered access to inputs and goods from the greater part of their home economy, businesses in Northern Ireland also have just as much right to have a voice in the Parliament making the economic laws to which they are subject, as the rest of the UK and the EU.”
The Stormont Brake is a mechanism that allows a minimum of 30 Stormont MLAs, from at least two parties, to refer a proposed EU law change to the UK Government.
The Government then makes an assessment of the proposed change on Northern Ireland and can ultimately veto its application in the region.
If the Government had ruled that the brake had been appropriately pulled, it would have directly engaged with the EU to find a solution.
This is the second time that a request has been made for the brake to be used, and the second time the request has been rejected.
In January 2025, the UK Government rejected the use of the mechanism to halt the application of EU rules on packaging and labelling of chemicals that applied in Northern Ireland.
